HomeMy WebLinkAboutDocumentation_Workshop_Tab 05_06/03/2019Agenda Item #5.
ar r�
Ja" �G�ia
Workshop
STAFF •
R� S9tl�
Meeting: Workshop - Jun 03 2019
Staff Contact: Keith Davis Department: Legal
Discuss Request for Accommodation (ADA) Letter by Juan Carlos Gill
See attached Memo
POTENTIAL MOTION / DIRECTION REQUESTED:
attachedSee Memo
ADA Compliancy Memo 6-3-19
Juan Carlos Gill Letter
Gill RAcc Response 2019
Page 68 of 77
Agenda Item #5.
Memorandum
To: Honorable Mayor and Village Council
Thru: James M. Weinand, Acting Village Manager
From: Lori McWilliams, MMC, Village Clerk
Date: 5/20/19
Subject: Request for Accommodation — Juan Carlos Gill
On May 2, 2019, the Village Clerk's Office received the attached "Request for
Accommodation" letter from Mr. Gill. Prior to receiving this letter, the manager asked
me to look into companies that could remediate our website files to make them ADA
compliant. The lowest cost remediation I could locate is $3.95 hour through ADA Site
Compliance. Mr. LaBadie (their representative and a Tequesta resident) ran a crawler
on our page and found 2,252 files and documents that require remediation:
Website documents & files
2,252 X $3.95 = $8,895.40
If we were to do the ADA remediation in-house of our website files/documents, the cost
would run approximately $81,072 to hire a part-time staffer to remediate the files (2
hours per page X $18/hour = $81,072).
Recommendation: Hire ADA Site Compliance to remediate all website
files/documents. This will save staff time and ensure all current website files are
compliant. Going forward, staff would be responsible for ensuring their webpage files
were compliant.
After receiving Mr. Gill's letter, legal asked
Mr. Gill requested from the Village's Doc
crawler on our Document Center for the d
remediate:
me what it would cost to remediate the files
iment Center. Mr. LaBadie again ran his
ites requested and found 17,392 records to
Agenda & Documentation 2016-2018 17,392 pages X $3.95 per page = $68,698
Page 69 of 77
Agenda Item #5.
Mr. LaBadie recommended the Village remove any files from our document center that
are not required in order to lower future costs of remediation. However, as Council has
discussed, that would remove transparency. Going forward, as we need to remediate
or create ADA documents, it would be a flat rate of $3.95 per page. He advised it takes
approximately 2 weeks to remediate 1,000 pages.
Recommendation: No recommendation by the Clerk.
Page 70 of 77
r,
JUAN CARLOS GIL
2656 SW 28a' Avenue
Miami, FL 33133
3/26/19
Via US Mail
Village of Tequesta, Florida
345 Tequesta Drive
Tequesta, FL 33469
Attn: Lori McWilliams, Village Clerk/Admin PIO
REQUEST FOR ACCOMMODATION
Dear Lori McWilliams;
RECEIVED
tAlAY - 2 IM
VILLAGE CLERKS OFFICE
On 3/25/19 I went to your information site (the website www.teauesta.orel trying to learn
about the governmental functioning of the Village of Tequesta, Florida through the documents
you provide within your site.
I am legally blind, so I depend on a screen reader to help me understand electronic
documents. My screen reader would not work with your electronic documents. I was specifically
interested in documents related to the budget of the Village of Tequesta, Florida (electronic
documents) for 2018, 2017, 2016 and 2015 and all Village Commission agendas and back up
material for year 2018, 2017 and 2016. Would you please make these documents accessible in
your site so that they will work with screen readers?
1 have visited www.tequesta.org in the past and I continue to desire to visit
www.tequesta.org in order to become an active participant in the Village of Tequesta, Florida
governmental process and to become informed about the programs, services and activities
offered by the Village of Tequesta, Florida as related to my intended future visits to the Village
ofTequesta, Florida.
Your site has many other electronic documents other than the specific ones which I have
asked for above. In addition to the specific documents listed here, can you also make the other
electronic documents within your site accessible so that they will work with screen readers so I
don't have to take the steps to ask for each document in a mail request?
I appreciate your reply as soon as possible.
Thank you,
-p X
m uan o 1
m
V_
O
r
Agenda Item #5.
�I■ DAVIS
ASHTON, P.A.
May 7, 2019
Juan Carlos Gil
2656 SW 28th Avenue
Miami, Florida 33133
Keith W. Davis, Esq.
Florida Bar Board Certified Attorney
City, County and Local Government Law
Email: keith@davisashtonlaw.com
Re: Request for Accommodation, Village of Tequesta, Florida, Website Documents.
Dear Mr. Gil:
I have been provided with your correspondence dated March 26, 2019 originally
received by Tequesta Village Clerk McWilliams on May 2, 2019, regarding the above
referenced matter. The Village appreciates (as have many other municipalities to whom
you have sent the identical letter you sent to Tequesta) your appetite for learning about
its governmental functions, and we welcome you to personally attend any public Village
functions as you promise you intend to do. Our Village Council meets regularly on the
second Thursday of each month at 6:00 pm in the Tequesta Village Council Chambers.
Be advised that the Village has already implemented a comprehensive Website
Transition Action Plan. In 2018, the Village initiated a third -party website audit for ADA
compliance. Said audit identified compliance issues which the Village has since been
diligently working on resolving. However, this is a work in progress and it is both
laborious and time consuming. This is not a process that can be completed "over -night"
but it is a process that is well underway. For your convenience, I have attached a copy
of the Village's Website Transition Action Plan to this letter.
In terms of the specific documents that you have requested to review (the 2015-2018
Village budgets and 2016-2018 Village Council meeting agendas and back up
materials), we have prioritized the effort to ensure the readability of these documents
via screen reader. Village staff is working with multiple service providers to obtain the
most efficient conversion available. Nevertheless, your request captures voluminous
documents which will take time to fully convert. It is our hope that this process Oust for
the records you have requested) can be completed in the next 120 days; however, this
timeframe cannot be guaranteed. We will advise you periodically as the documents you
have requested have been uploaded in a readable format. In the meantime, should you
701 Northpoint Parkway, Suite 205, West Palm Beach, FL 33407 1 p 561-586-7116 1 f 561-586-9611
www.davisashtonlaw.com
♦ LEADING EXPERTS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT LAW AND ETHICS
Page 72 of 77
Agenda Item #5.
May 7, 2019
Response to Request for Accommodation
require any further assistance, please contact the Village Clerk by calling (561) 768-
0443 or by e-mailing the Village Clerk at Imcwilliams@tequesta.org.
Once again, on behalf of the Village, its officials and staff, we are excited that you (a
resident of Miami) are interested to learn more about Tequesta. We look forward to
meeting you in person during your upcoming promised visit.
Enclosure
cc: J. Weinand, Acting Village Manager
L. McWilliams, Village Clerk
Sincerely,
Keith W. Davis, Esq.
Village Attorney
2 Page 73 of 77