Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDocumentation_Regular_Tab 11_1/12/2023Agenda Item #11 0 Regular Council STAFF MEMO Meeting: Staff Contact: Regular Council - Jan 12 2023 Nilsa Zacarias, Director of Community Development C-3 Department: Community Development ORDINANCE NO. 02-23, FIRST READING, AN ORDINANCE OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE VILLAGE CODE OF ORDINANCES AT CHAPTER 78. ZONING., ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL., SEC. 78-4. DEFINITIONS. TO CREATE A NEW DEFINITION FOR THE TERM "DESIGN GUIDELINES"; AT ARTICLE VI. SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-143. SCHEDULE OF SITE REQUIREMENTS. TO REVISE THE FRONT AND SIDE YARD SETBACK REQUIREMENTS FOR THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AT ARTICLE VI. SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-175. R-3 MULTI -FAMILY DWELLING DISTRICT. TO MAKE REFERENCE TO DESIGN GUIDELINES AS A TOOL FOR COMPLETING DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS FOR PROPERTIES IN THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AND AT ARTICLE IX. SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-289. LOCATION OF ACCESSORY BUILDINGS. TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND BUILDINGS EAST OF BEACH ROAD; AND AT CHAPTER 22. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT., ARTICLE II. COMMUNITY APPEARANCE. TO AMEND SEC. 22-82. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS RELATIVE TO SITE PLAN REVIEW. TO MAKE REFERENCE TO DESIGN GUIDELINES AS A TOOL FOR COMPLETING DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS FOR PROPERTIES IN THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AND AT CHAPTER 10. ANIMALS. ARTICLE III. SEA TURTLE PROTECTION., SEC. 10- 67. SEA TURTLE PROTECTION PLAN REQUIRED. TO ADOPT PALM BEACH COUNTY'S TURTLE PROTECTION REGULATIONS; PROVIDING THAT EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 10. ANIMALS, AND CHAPTER 22 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, AND CHAPTER 78. ZONING SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. Revised Ordinance 15-22, which was previously heard and discussed at the December 8th Village Council meeting. This document and any attachments may be reproduced upon request in an alternative format by completing our Accessibility Feedback Form, sending an e-mail to the Village Clerk or calling 561-768- 0443. PROJECT NAME: BUDGET: N/A ENCUMBERED: N/A Proposed: Projected Remaining: N/A N/A Page 154 of 396 Agenda Item #11 0 Ordinance & Design Guidelines Memo Ord. 02-23 Design Guidelines Ordinance Page 155 of 396 Agenda Item #11 0 Law DAvis & ASSOCIATES,P.,A, Keith W. Davis, Esq. Florida Bar Board Certified Attorney in City, County and Local Government Email: keith@davislawteam.com MEMORANDUM TO: Village Manager Allen for Distribution to Village Council FROM: Village Attorney Davis DATE: January 1, 2023 RE: Ordinances 15-22 and 16-22; R-3 Design Guidelines At the December 8, 2022 Village Council meeting, the Village Council considered the above three (3) referenced items at a public hearing. During the public hearing, the Village Council heard presentations from Village staff regarding these items, and also heard from legal counsel representing property owners who reside at 350 Beach Road (Island House Northeast) and 325 Beach Road (Island House Southwest) both of whom voiced certain objections to the ordinances and the design guidelines as presented. Following the staff and resident presentations, the Village Council thoroughly debated and discussed the guidelines and the ordinances and took different action on each of the three (3) items: 1. The Design Guidelines were adopted, with direction given to Village staff to conform them to the changes made to Ordinances 15-22 and 16-22, and to remove reference to green building design. The Village Council will have an opportunity to further comment on the revised Design Guidelines and approve the edits that have been made at the January 12, 2023 Village Council meeting. 2. Ordinance 15-22 was not adopted on First Reading. Instead, the Village Council directed Village staff to remove all revisions to existing rear setback requirements, and to also consider the objections made by legal counsel for the Island House residents and revise the ordinance to be considered on First Reading again at the January 12, 2023 Village Council meeting. 3. Ordinance 16-22 was adopted on First Reading but without the proposed revisions to the existing off-street parking requirements, and will be heard on Second Reading at the January 12, 2023 Village Council meeting as edited. The following portions of this Memorandum will list the edits that have been made to the Design Guidelines, and to Ordinances 15-22 and 16-22 per Village Council direction; and will also discuss comments on the edits received from the Island House residents through their legal counsel: 7o1 Northpoint Parkway, Suite 205, West Palm Beach, FL 33407 I p 561-586-7116 I f 561 586-9611 ***. davislawteam. com 0 LEADING ATTORNEYS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT LAW AND ETHICS 0 Page 156 of 396 Agenda Item #11. January 1, 2023 Design Guidelines, Ordinances 15-22, and 16-22; Edits Following 12/08/22 Village Council meeting Page No. 2 DESIGN GUIDELINES Village staff has made the following edits to the approved Design Guidelines per Village Council direction: 1. Graphics depicting the previously proposed rear setback have been removed (pp. 87 9). 2. Terms "shall" or "must" have been chanaed to "should" throuahout the document. 3. All reference to green building design have been removed from the body of the document, from the appendix, and from the checklist (pp. 293 303 51, 55). ORDINANCE 15-22 The Village Attorney has made the following edits to Ordinance 15-22 per Village Council direction: 1. A new "WHEREAS" clause was added to address the Village's Comprehensive Plan Private property Rights Element. 2. The definition of "Design Guidelines" was edited to add language that clearly explains the guidelines are not, in and of themselves, approval criteria in any quasi-judicial proceeding, but rather are meant to be a tool to be used by applicants in meeting the existing aesthetic requirements contained on Ch. 22 Art. II of the Village Code. 3. Proposed changes to R-3 rear setback requirements were removed completely. 4. R-3 side setback requirements were edited by "smoothing out" the current "pyramid / wedding cake" step-in requirements. The result is a slightly greater setback requirement at the bottom of the building and a slightly reduced setback requirement at the top of the building. 5. New language was placed in both the R-3 zoning code and the Ch. 22 aesthetic requirement code which reiterates the fact that the design guidelines are meant to be a tool to be used by applicants to meet existing code requirements and are not, in and of themselves, approval criteria in any quasi-judicial proceeding. 6. The ordinance title was conformed to the above edits. ORDINANCE 16-22 The Village Attorney has made the following edits to Ordinance 16-22 per Village Council direction: 1. The section that previously provided edits to the Villages off-street parking code and proposed new requirements for guest parking was removed completely. 2. The ordinance title was conformed to the above edits. 3. The ordinance "WHEREAS" clauses were conformed to the above edits. 7o1 Northpoint Parkway, Suite 205, West Palm Beach, FL 33407 I p 561-586-7116 I f 561 586-9611 ***. davislawteam. com 0 LEADING ATTORNEYS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT LAW AND ETHICS 0 Page 157 of 396 Agenda Item #11. January 1, 2023 Design Guidelines, Ordinances 15-22, and 16-22; Edits Following 12/08/22 Village Council meeting Page No. 3 Legal counsel representing the residents at 325 and 350 Beach Road were provided with the above three (3) revised documents and were given ample opportunity to review and comment on same. Mr. Brian Seymour provided written comments dated December 30, 2022. Other than a minor comment regarding landscaping requirements in the rear yard, and a minor comment suggesting that the design guidelines should not be the only way an applicant can demonstrate compliance with existing aesthetic requirements contained on Ch. 22 Art. II of the Village Code, Mr. Seymour expressed his clients' appreciation for the edits that have been made since the December 8, 2022 Village Council meeting and stated that there were no further objections to the documents. Mr. Ron Klein spoke to me last week and also expressed appreciation for the edits that have been made to the design guidelines and the ordinances since the December 8, 2022 Village Council meeting. Although Mr. Klein joined with Mr. Seymour in Mr. Seymour's minor comments, he also advised me that there were no further objections to the documents. Mr. Seymour's December 30, 2022 e-mail comments are attached to this Memorandum for your review. 7o1 Northpoint Parkway, Suite 205, West Palm Beach, FL 33407 I p 561-586-7116 I f 561 586-9611 ***. davislawteam. com 0 LEADING ATTORNEYS IN LOCAL GOVERNMENT LAW AND ETHICS 0 Page 158 of 396 Agenda Item #11 0 Lance Lilly From: Keith Davis <keith@davislawteam.com> Sent: Tuesday, January 3, 2023 11:01 AM To: Lance Lilly Subject: [EXTERNAL] FW: Final comments on design guidelines and ordinances 15 and16 **This Email was sent from an external source. Please be mindful of its content** From: Seymour, Brian <BSeymour@gunster.com> Sent: Friday, December 30, 2022 3:45 PM To: Keith Davis <keith@davislawteam.com>; ron.klein@hklaw.com Cc: Jeremy Allen <jallen@tequesta.org>; Nilsa Zacarias <nzacarias@tequesta.org> Subject: RE: Final comments on design guidelines and ordinances 15 and16 Keith, I am still waiting to hear from all board members. But, I think that we are good and I know that you have a deadline. First, thank you for considering our points, particularly adding in some additional clarity in Section 22-82(14). Though we would prefer it as a separate section not under the criteria, and that it be stated that these are not the only method of meeting the requirements, we also understand that the Council will follow your guidance and they have all made clear on the record that this is not meant to be criteria, which means it also cannot be the only way to meet the Code requirements. So, hopefully this will never be an issue that will have to be dealt with. We did review the Design Guidelines again. The issue that I raised about Ordinance 16 was what I mentioned at the last hearing. We want to be sure that the 5' rear landscape buffer does not become a de facto setback. We understand that is not the intent, and that the intent is not to have views blocked along the water (which is of course a huge value issue), and that the landscape can be incorporated into the development (e.g., as part of a pool deck or walkways). If that can be confirmed, we would appreciate it. Otherwise, we do not object to the changes as proposed. I hope you all have a happy new year. Brian Ll N S F LO RIDA S i. AW PtR e Olt BUSM9S Brian M. Seymour I Attorney Real Property Practice, Co -Chair Business Litigation Practice 777 South F[ag[er Drive, Suite 500 East Page 159 of 396 Agenda Item #11 0 West Palm Beach, FL 33401 P 561-650-0621 F 561-655-5677 gunster.com Find me on : Twitter I Linkedln Email me: bseymour@gunster.com From: Keith Davis <keith@davislawteam.com> Sent: Friday, December 30, 2022 7:12 AM To: Seymour, Brian <BSeymour@gunster.com>; ron.klein@hklaw.com Cc: Jeremy Allen <aallen@teguesta.org>; Nilsa Zacarias <nzacarias@teguesta.org> Subject: Final comments on design guidelines and ordinances 15 and16 Brian & Ron: Wishing you both a Happy New Year. Looking forward to working with you both next year in a spirit of collaboration and cooperation. Please provide me your comments on the design guidelines and the ordinances in a "bullet point" format if possible so can include them in the agenda item back up for the January 12 Council meeting. Remember, ordinance 15 will be back for First Reading again fresh, ordinance 16 will be back on Second Reading, and the design guidelines will be back to show conformance with the ordinances and for the Council to approve the conforming edits to the document that was approved in December. Keith W. Davis, Esquire Attorney W51M DAVIS EMASSOCIATES,P.A. 701 Northpoint Parkway, Suite 205 West Palm Beach, Florida 33407 Tel: (561) 586-7116 PREEMINENTpw.��ft 14111hamt Lwn'T2022 Incoming a -mails are filtered which may delay receipt. This e-mail is personal to the named recipient(s) and may be privileged and confidential. If you are not the intended recipient, you received this in error. If so, any review, dissemination, or copying of this e-mail is prohibited. Please notify us immediately by e-mail and delete the original message. Page 160 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 ORDINANCE NO. 02-23 AN ORDINANCE OF THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA, FLORIDA, AMENDING THE VILLAGE CODE OF ORDINANCES AT CHAPTER 78. ZONING., ARTICLE I. IN GENERAL., SEC. 78-4. DEFINITIONS. TO CREATE A NEW DEFINITION FOR THE TERM "DESIGN GUIDELINES"; AT ARTICLE VI. SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-143. SCHEDULE OF SITE REQUIREMENTS. TO REVISE THE FRONT AND SIDE YARD SETBACK REQUIREMENTS FOR THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AT ARTICLE VI. SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-175. R-3 MULTI -FAMILY DWELLING DISTRICT. TO MAKE REFERENCE TO DESIGN GUIDELINES AS A TOOL FOR COMPLETING DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS FOR PROPERTIES IN THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AND AT ARTICLE IX. SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS., SEC. 78-289. LOCATION OF ACCESSORY BUILDINGS. TO PROVIDE ADDITIONAL REGULATIONS FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURES AND BUILDINGS EAST OF BEACH ROAD; AND AT CHAPTER 22. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT., ARTICLE II. COMMUNITY APPEARANCE. TO AMEND SEC. 22-82. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS RELATIVE TO SITE PLAN REVIEW. TO MAKE REFERENCE TO DESIGN GUIDELINES AS A TOOL FOR COMPLETING DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS FOR PROPERTIES IN THE R-3 ZONING DISTRICT; AND AT CHAPTER 10. ANIMALS. ARTICLE III. SEA TURTLE PROTECTION., SEC. 10-67. SEA TURTLE PROTECTION PLAN REQUIRED. TO ADOPT PALM BEACH COUNTY'S TURTLE PROTECTION REGULATIONS; PROVIDING THAT EACH AND EVERY OTHER SECTION AND SUBSECTION OF CHAPTER 10. ANIMALS, AND CHAPTER 22 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, AND CHAPTER 78. ZONING SHALL REMAIN IN FULL FORCE AND EFFECT AS PREVIOUSLY ADOPTED; PROVIDING A CONFLICTS CLAUSE, A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE AND AUTHORITY TO CODIFY; PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE, AND FOR OTHER PURPOSES. WHEREAS, in recent years, the Beach Road Corridor has experienced redevelopment due to the increasing demands in the real estate market which has triggered new planning, zoning, design, and environmental challenges; and WHEREAS, Village Staff developed the Beach Road Corridor Design Guidelines ("Design Guidelines") to help guide desired redevelopment in a direction that maintains and even enhances Tequesta's small village, pedestrian way of life, as well as its urban character, and scenic charm throughout the Beach Road corridor; and 1 Page 161 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 WHEREAS, certain code revisions are also required to update unusable setback codes, update accessory building codes, update regulations related to sea turtle protection, and generally reflect the realities of 21 St Century development and re- development within the R-3 Zoning District; and WHEREAS, the Village Council desires to reference the Design Guidelines by ordinance, and adopt the zoning code revisions proposed in this ordinance; and WHEREAS, Village staff, in preparing this ordinance, and the Village Council, in adopting this ordinance, have considered and complied with the mandates of the recently adopted Private Property Rights Element of the Village of Tequesta Comprehensive Development Plan; and WHEREAS, the Village Council has determined that the code amendments contained in this ordinance will be in the best interests of the citizens of the Village of Tequesta, and will serve to promote the public health, safety and welfare. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA, PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA AS FOLLOWS: Section 1: Chapter 78. Zoning. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article I. In General. by amending Section 78-4. Definitions. to add an entirely new definition for the term "Design guidelines"; providing that Section 78-4 shall hereafter read as follows: Sec. 78-4. Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this chapter, unless otherwise specified, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning. All words used in the present tense include the future; all words in the singular number include the plural and the plural the singular. The word "building" includes the word "structure." The word "shall" is mandatory. The word "person" includes a firm, corporation or municipal corporation as well as a natural person. The word "map" shall mean the official zoning map of the village. The term "council" shall mean the Council of the Village of Tequesta and the word "village" shall mean the Village of Tequesta, a municipal corporation of the State 2 Page 162 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 of Florida. The word "used" shall be deemed to include the words "arranged, designed or intended to be used," and the word "occupied" shall be deemed to include the words "arranged, designed or intended to be occupied." Any word or term not interpreted or defined by this section shall be used with a meaning of common or standard utilization. Design Guidelines refers to the Village of Teauesta's architectural and design goals for the R-3 Zoning District. The Design Guidelines document includes descriptions, and explains the desired intent of the Village of Teauesta for the overall development and re -development of the R-3 Zoning District. The Design Guidelines offer examples and goals for applicants regarding building and landscape architecture, use of open space, sianage in conformance with Village Code, parking surface and structured in conformance with Village Code, loading zones in conformance with Village Code, ublic streetscapes, and building placement, scale/massing, height, and character. The intent of the Design Guidelines is to assist applicants in meeting Village Code requirements for building and site aesthetics contained in Chapter 22, Community Development, Article II. Community Appearance, Sec. 22-82. — General requirements relative to site plan review. The Design Guidelines are not in and of themselves approval criteria in any quasi-judicial proceeding. [All other definitions shall remain the same as previously adopted.] Section 2: Chapter 78. Zoning. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article VI. Schedule of District Regulations., Division 1. Schedule of Site Regulations. by amending Section 78-143. Schedule of site requirements. to revise the front and side yard setback requirements for the R-3 Zoning District; providing that Section 78-143 relative to the R-3 Zoning District shall hereafter read as follows: Sec. 78-143. - Schedule of site requirements. 3 Page 163 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 The following schedule establishes the minimum property and building regulations for development within the villager SCHEDULE OF SITE REQUIREMENTS Minimum Setbacks I Minimum Maximum Front Yard Side Yard Rear Yard Maximum Minimum Minimum District Lot Width Lot Building Living Landscaped Coverage Height Area Open Requirements Space R-3 80 ft. 35% 20 ft. for �20f+ nil ,s 2 f+ 20 ft. plus 2 ft. 11 stories / 101 1,500 sq. ft. 30% 200 ft.3 main structures or for eaGh s nal 10ft..-. thereof eve �n h ft. in oW- I inh�Zj T the mam-R for each additional 10 ft. or portion thereof over 50 ft. in height of the main building or ft. measured from the average height of the crest of the sand dune line, for main building or structure east of for the first 2 bedrooms, plus 225 sq. ft. for each additional bedroom. buildings ur)pertmen 40 ft. in h ei ht; 35 ft. for anv portion StFUGtWe. structure. Beach Road, thereof 20 ft. for main 10 ft. for any and measured structure or exceeding 40 ft. in accessory one- story building or structure. Plus 2 ft. for each additional story of the accessory building or stru ctu re. from grade west of Beach Road.4 2 stories/20 ft. for any accessory building or structure. buildings up hei 45 ft. for any to 40 ft. in hem 25 ft. for anv portion thereof exceeding 80 ft. i n o thereof exceed i n L==40 hei ft. in height but less than 0 10 ft. for an 80 feet in accessory structure not exceeding one story/10portion ft. in height used for the hem 30 ft. for any thereof exceeding ft. in heir parking of vehicles only 10 ft. for any (covered accessory one - parking) and story building provided that or structure. the design of Plus 2 ft. fnr the front of the oath addi+iGRa covered Ste.nl of the parking structure includes fully s ,^+ landscaped grade and/or raised 1 Only the schedule for the R-3 Zoning District is amended. The schedule for all other zoning districts remains in full force and effect as previously adopted. C! Page 164 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 planters that minima im of 10 IanrJSr+�norJ the full f rTrvrTt.age o f the Section 3: Chapter 78. Zoning. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article VI. Schedule of District Regulations., Division 2. Schedule of Use Regulations. by amending Section 78-175. R-3 Multi -family dwelling district. to reference Design Guidelines for use by applicants when preparing development or re -development applications for properties in the R-3 Zoning District; providing that Section 78-175 shall hereafter read as follows: Sec. 78-175. R-3 multiple -family dwelling district. (a) Purpose. It is the purpose and intent of the R-3 multiple -family dwelling district to provide lands within the village for a higher density range of multiple -family residential uses. In no event shall density exceed 12 dwelling units per gross acre. This district is further intended for development of concentrated residential populations and should be applied only within the high density designated areas as depicted by the comprehensive development plan. (b) Design Guidelines. Applications for development and re -development in the R-3 Zoning District shall utilize the Village's Design Guidelines including the Design Guidelines checklist in order to achieve compliance with the general requirements relative to site plan review set forth in Chapter 22, Article II. Sec. 22-82.. The Design Guidelines are found at Appendix E of the Village Code of Ordinances, and are kept on file with r- both the Village Clerk's Office and the Village's Community Development Office. -Mc�Permitted uses. Permitted uses in the R-3 district are as follows: (1) Multifamily dwellings. (2) Places of assembly (750 square feet or less), subject to the following conditions: 0 Page 165 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 a. All presentations and events shall be conducted entirely within a building; b. Allowed accessory uses are: preschool and school facilities; assembly halls, sanctuaries or similar meeting rooms; community centers or fellowship halls; administrative offices related to the facility; gift shops for merchandise related to the facility; playgrounds and athletic fields; and rectory or similar residence for facility officials or on -site caretakers, limited to one dwelling unit. kokMAccessory uses. Accessory uses allowed in the R-3 district are as follows: Private garages, swimming pools, spas and hot tubs, cabanas and saunas, greenhouses, tennis courts, clubhouses, private docks, dune crossovers, utility buildings, gazebos and any other similar uses deemed appropriate by the director of community development. 04Ue Special exception uses. Special exception uses in the R-3 district are as follows: (1) Schools and publicly owned and operated community buildings. (2) Public utility buildings such as water pumping plants and electric substations; police and fire stations. (3) Marina facilities. (4) Community antenna systems. (5) Parks and recreation facilities owned and operated by the village. (6) Foster care facilities, as may be required, regulated and licensed by applicable state statutes and agencies. (7) Group homes, as may be required, regulated and licensed by applicable state statutes and agencies. (8) Places of assembly (765 square feet or more), subject to the following conditions: a. All presentations and events shall be conducted entirely within a building. Page 166 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 b. Allowed accessory uses are: preschool and school facilities; assembly halls, sanctuaries or similar meeting rooms; community centers or fellowship halls; administrative offices related to the facility; gift shops for merchandise related to the facility; playgrounds and athletic fields; and rectory or similar residence for facility officials or on -site caretakers, limited to one dwelling unit. Wff)Prohibited uses and structures. The following uses and structures are prohibited in the R-3 district: Any use or structure not specifically or by reasonable implication permitted in this section as a permitted use, accessory use or permissible by special exception. Section 4: Chapter 78. Zoning. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article IX. Supplemental Regulations., Division 1. Generally. by amending Section 78-289. Location of accessory buildings. to provide additional regulations for accessory structures and buildings east of Beach Road; providing that Section 78-289 shall hereafter read as follows: Sec. 78-289. - Location of accessory buildings. (a) No accessory structure, except as otherwise provided by this chapter, shall be located in the area between the front setback line of the principal structure and the street line unless such lot fronts Beach Road. (b) Where the accessory structure is attached to the principal structure or connected thereto by a breezeway, the side yard shall be measured from the outer wall thereof. Section 5: Chapter 22. Community Development. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article II. Community Appearance. by amending Section 22-82. General requirements relative to site plan review. to reference Design Guidelines for use by applicants when preparing development or re- development applications for properties in the R-3 Zoning District; providing that Section 22-82 shall hereafter read as follows: 0 Page 167 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 Sec. 22-82. - General requirements relative to site plan review. The planning and zoning board or the Village Council, as applicable, shall review, and recommend or take final action, as applicable, t"o VoliPme Ge �na;l ^r tpkQ find P�.t ,16...If, pursuant to subsection 22-53(a) and (b). In making such review, the planning and zoning board or the Village Council, as applicable, shall apply the following general requirements: The general requirements are minimum aesthetic standards for all site development, buildings, structures, or alterations within the village except in districts R-1 A and R-1. It is required that site development, buildings or alterations, with the sole exception of districts R-1 A and R-1, show proper design concept, express honest design construction and be appropriate to the surroundings. (1) Harmony with other buildings. Buildings or structures which are a part of a present or future group or complex shall have a unity of character and design, and a relationship of forms, and the use, texture and color of materials shall be such as to create an harmonious whole. When the area involved forms an integral part of, is immediately adjacent to or otherwise clearly affects the future of any established section of the village, the design and location on the site shall enhance rather than detract from the character, value, and attractiveness of the surroundings. (2) Harmony with surroundings. Buildings or structures located along strips of land or on single sites and not a part of a unified multibuilding complex shall strive to achieve visual harmony with the surroundings. If they are built in undeveloped areas, the three primary requirements shall be met: express honest design construction, show proper design concepts, and be appropriate to the village. (3) Facades. All facades visible to public or adjacent property shall be designed to create a harmonious whole. Materials shall express their function clearly and not appear as a material foreign to the rest of the building. (4) Methods of harmonious design. It is not to be inferred that buildings must look alike or be of the same style to be harmonious. Harmony can be achieved Page 168 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 through the proper consideration of proportions, site planning, landscaping, materials and color. (5) Advertisements on buildings. Buildings which are of symbolic design for reasons of advertising and are not compatible to the atmosphere of the village shall not be approved. Symbols attached to the buildings will not be allowed unless they are secondary in appearance to the building and landscape and are an aesthetic asset to the project and neighborhood. (6) Exterior lighting. Exterior lighting may be used to illuminate a building and its grounds for safety purposes, but in an aesthetic manner. Lighting is not to be used as a form of advertising in a manner that is not compatible to the neighborhood or in a manner such that it draws considerably more attention to the building grounds at night than in the day. Lighting following the form of the building or part of the building will not be allowed. All fixtures used in exterior lighting are to be selected not only for functional value, but for aesthetic value. (7) Inappropriate building styles. Buildings of a style or style type foreign to South Florida and/or its climate will not be allowed. It is also to be understood that buildings, even though they have a historical significance to South Florida, that do not conform to the existing or to the evolving atmosphere of the village will not be approved. (8) Garish design. Building surfaces, walls and roofs that are considered garish by the board will be denied approval. (9) Takeout and pickup windows. Takeout or pickup windows of retail or wholesale establishments shall not be located on a building facade that faces a public right- of-way, unless they are designed in such a manner as to be an aesthetic asset to the building and neighborhood. (10) Exterior forms. All exterior forms, attached or not attached to buildings, shall be in conformity to and secondary to the building. They shall be an asset both to the aesthetics of the site and to the neighborhood. (11) Telephones, vending machines, and facilities dispensing merchandise or services. All telephones on private property, vending machines, or any facility 9 Page 169 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 dispensing merchandise or a service shall be confined to a space built into the building or enclosed in a separate structure compatible with the main building. (12) Advertisements on amenities. No advertising will be allowed on any exposed amenity or facility such as benches and trash containers. (13) Use of symbolic colors; exterior storage and display of merchandise. The following are added criteria that pertain to but are not limited to gasoline stations. Symbolic colors of the exterior facades or roofs may not be used unless they are harmonious with the atmosphere of the neighborhood. For example, royal blue, which symbolizes a brand of gasoline and other establishments, would not be acceptable in most cases. Exterior display of goods for sale or those designating a service will not be allowed, except that a gasoline station's display of goods and tools of a service may be displayed on the pump island, provided that the island is not considered by the board to be enlarged to take advantage of this provision, and provided that the goods and tools be such that they can be used or installed at the island. For example, an oil rack is acceptable, but a tire display is not. Areas used to store materials such as mufflers, tires, packing crates or cases, refuse and garbage shall be screened from adjacent property and from the public view. (14) Applications for develoament and re -development in the R-3 Zoning District shall utilize the Village's Design Guidelines including the Design Guidelines checklist in order to achieve compliance with the general requirements relative to r- site plan review set forth in this section. The Design Guidelines are found at Appendix E of the Village Code of Ordinances, and are kept on file with both the Village Clerk's Office and the Village's Community Development Office. Section 6: Chapter 10. Animals. of the Code of Ordinances of the Village of Tequesta is hereby amended at Article III. Sea Turtle Protection. by amending Section 10-67. Sea turtle protection plan required. to adopt Palm Beach County's turtle protection regulations; providing that Section 10-67 shall hereafter read as follows: Sec. 10-67. - Sea turtle protection plan required. 10 Page 170 of 396 Agenda Item #11. First Reading January 12, 2023 A sea turtle protection plan shall be required for the following activities and shall include any and all protective/mitigative measures that will be implemented in conjunction with these activities: (1) All coastal construction within jurisdictional boundaries involving the installation of permanently mounted light fixtures. (2) All coastal construction conducted during the nesting season (March 1 through October 31), seaward of the dune, within jurisdictional boundaries, including site development and mechanical beach cleaning. (3) The Village adheres to the County's turtle protection regulations as specified in article 14, chapter A of Palm Beach County's Unified Land Development Code. No building permit or certificate of occupancy shall be issued until all requirements of the county's turtle protection regulations have been met. Section 7: Each and every other Section and Subsection of Chapter 10. Animals., Chapter 22. Community Appearance. And Chapter 78. Zoning. shall remain in full force and effect as previously adopted. Section 8: All ordinances or parts of ordinances in conflict be and the same are hereby repealed. Section 9: Should any section or provision of this Ordinance or any portion thereof, any paragraph, sentence or word be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remainder of this Ordinance. Section 10: Specific authority is hereby granted to codify this Ordinance. Section 11: This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon adoption. 11 Page 171 of 396