Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDocumentation_Regular_Tab 7C_2/13/1997 j 351.Cald t. is?'-- ---- `, VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA Post Office Box 3273 • 357 Tequesta Drive `� N� Tequesta,Florida 33469-0273 • (407) 575-6200 K- 44 -4 Fax: (407)575-6203 ...9,41N-4.Ps.? COUN • TEQUESTA MUNICIPAL FIREFIGHTER'S PENSION TRUST FUND BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING JUNE 7, 1996 i I . CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL The Tequesta Municipal Firefighter' s Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees held a regularly scheduled meeting at the Village Hall, 357 Tequesta Drive, Tequesta, Florida, op Friday, June •7, - 1 96. The meeting 4as called to order at 8:58' A.M. by Chairman Ron Mackail. A roll call was taken by Betty Laur, the Recording Secretary. Boardmembers in attendance at the meeting were: Chairman Ron T. Mackail, Boardmember Thomas G. Bradford, Boardmember Bill Sharpless, Boardmember Shawn Thurman, and Boardmember James B. Trube. Also in attendance was Finance Director Bill Kascavelis and Attorney Scott Hawkins, sitting in for Village Attorney John C. Randolph. II. APPROVAL OP. AGINDA Boardmember Bradford requested addition under Any Other Matters of discussion of the proposed employee pension trust fund. Boardmember Sharpless made a motion to approve the agenda as amended. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Ron T. Mackail - for y i Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 2 Tom Bradford - for Bill Sharpless - for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted and the Agenda was approved as amended. III. APPROVAL OF PREVIOUS MEETING MINUTES (Meeting Minutes of March 18, 1996) Boardmember Bradford moved to approve the minutes of the March 18, 1996 meeting of the Tequesta Municipal Firefighters Pension Trust. Fund Board of Trustees as \ amended with minor changes Which Boardmember',Sharpless stated that he had requested. The motion was seconded by Boardmember Trube. The vote on the motion was: Ron T. Mackail - for Tom Bradford for - Bill Sharpiess for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube for the motion was therefore passed and adopted and the minutes were approved as amended. IV. NOTIFICATION TO BOARDWOOMMS OF TEE APPOINTMENT OF JAMBS B. TRUBE AS TRUSTEE, ELECTED BY FIRBFIGETNRS. Boardmember Bradford explained that Lieutenant Trube had been elected by his full-time firefighter co-workers to be one of their two representatives on the Board. Boardmember Trube was welcomed by the other Boardmembers. f Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 3 V. CONSIDERATION OF RE-APPOINTMENT OF BOARD MEMBER WILLIAM SEARPLESS TO A TWO YEAR TERM COMMENCING JUNE 9, 1996. _ A) Discussion B) Recommendations Chairman Mackail discussed the added value which Mr. Sharpless had provided to the Board as an excellent Boardmember and recommended that Mr. Sharpless be re- appointed. The other Boardmembers agreed. Boardmember Bradford made a motion to re-appoint Mr. William Sharpless as a member of the Board for a two-year term commencing June 9, 1996. Boardmember Trube seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Ron T. Mackail - . f r Tom Bradford - fo Bill Sharpless - for \ Shawn. Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. VI. PRESENTATION BY STEVE PALIQDIST, GABRIEL, ROEDER, SNITS AND COMPANY, INC., FOR CONSIDERATION OF PENSION PLAN ACTUARIAL SERVICES AND Rgcommimmaslow FOR PENSION PLAN ADMINISTRATOR AND INVESTMENT MANAGE ENT SERVICES. A) Discussion Mr. Palmquist distributed a copy of his company' s proposal, which has been attached to and made a part of these minutes. Mr. Palmquist explained that his firm was an actuarial consulting firm, fully owned by its 100+ employees, who had merged in September with another firm who had employed Mr., Palmquist. Mr. Palmquist stated he had been with the two companies total of 23 years, and if the Board accepted his company's proposal, he would be Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 4 the representative for the Village. Mr. Palmquist explained that his company was an authority in the field of governmental pension plans, which was their specialty. Included in the list of services his firm would provide for a fee of $2, 800 per year were individual benefit statements for each employee, which Mr. Palmquist explained was very important. Also included were an annual actuarial valuation report, calculation of benefits for any person who left the plan and was eligible for benefits, determination of the actuarial impact for up to two changes in plan benefits, and up to two meetings with the Board (one to go over the actuarial report plus another at the discretion of the Village) . Mr. Palmquist explained that he would be in the area very often since his office was in Ft. Lauderdale and his home -was in Vero Beach. \ -.Boardmember Trube questioned the amount of hourly rates which would be charged for other services. Mr. Palmquist responded that rates ranged from $50 to $180 an hour (his rate) , and that the lower rate people were used as much as possible to keep fees down. Examples of other services for which hourly fees would be charged could include more than 2 meetings annually, more than two studies annually, or possibly filing a letter of determination with the IRS. Boardmember Bradford reported concern among the Boardmembers regarding the annual requirement for an actuarial study by the Florida League of Cities at a cost of $4, 000. Boardmember Bradford commented that his impression was that if the Board chose to take advantage of Mr. Palmquist' s services that more hands-on service would be available with his company for less money than was currently being paid, however, the Board would have to take care of the financial advisor aspects of the plan provisions. Mr. Palmquist questioned whether the $4, 000 included investment advisory fees. Boardmember Bradford Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 5 reported those were separate. Finance Director Kascavelis commented that the Florida League of Cities provided a total service package at an annual cost .of approximately 1-1/2% of the fund assets, and he had a letter from them regarding that issue. Mr. Palmquist explained that almost all funds had outside managers, just like the Village had Atlanta Capital through -the Florida League of Cities, and commented that the Village could probably get a separate contract with Atlanta Capital if the Village liked them. Mr. Palmquist( explained that there were a number of good investment firms in Florida, and some of the banks were good. Fees would depend upon the amount of assets, but usually began at 3/4 of 1% for the first million dollars with the percentage decreasing for assets in excess of one million, atnd the Village should not have any problem locating an investment manager for fees less than 1% of assets. Imo'. Palmquist stated that although he would be wary of buying no load mutual funds, that the fee structure for stock funds was approximately 1% and bond funds less than 1a. . Mr. Palmquist advised that his company could direct the Village to -investment managers; or many such contacts could be made at conferences. Boardmember Sharpless questioned whether it was practical to invest a $300, 000 fund alone, to which Mr. Palmquist responded that whoever managed the Village's fund would probably be using commingled funds specifically set up to meet Chapter 175 or 185 requirements. Mr. Palmquist stated that Sun Bank, Barnett Bank, and First Union were all very knowledgeable. Finance Director Kascavelis reported that expenses for this year would total $7,000, with $4, 000 designated for actuarial services by the Florida League of Cities. Boardmesnber Sharpless pointed out that $7,000 was over 2% of assets. • Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 6 Boardmember Bradford expressed his opinion that the Board needed to look at the other side of the equation, the financial side, before .. a decision could be made. Boardmember Bradford highly recommended Mr. Palmquist and his firm, and commented that if the financial piece of the puzzle fit and the Village could come out ahead he would recommend that their services be retained. Finance Director Kascavelis reported that the past year' s total expenses were $5, 347, including the $4, 000 designated for actuarial services. Boardmember Bradford recommended that actual costs be recomputed and clarified for the Board, and that financial advisement services from other sources besides the Florida League of Cities be investigated. Chairman Mackail questioned the necessity, or..an annual actuarial audit since the plan was so new and the,,ages of the firefighters young, to which Imo'. Palmquist responded that the State requirement was once every three years, that the annual audit made up the biggest part of their proposed annual $2, 800 fee, and that the governmental requirement was going to be changed to once every other year. Mr. Palmquist explained that the significance of a determination letter was that the IRS would state that the plan was tax deferred, and although the possibility that it would ever be needed was very remote, the Village would have that proof if any problems ever arose. Finance Director Rascavelis stated he would check with Florida League of Cities to see if they had filed for a determination letter. Chairman Mackail requested that Mr. Kascavelis obtain a copy of the determination letter. Mr. Palmquist volunteered to provide 3-4 names of people who did investments and could give a quick idea of their fees. Finance Director Kascavelis was 'asked to make those contacts and to provide the information to the Board. Chairman Mackail commented that he assumed any change would be made near the September 30 year end. Mt. Palmquist explained that their company had an asset consulting group who helped find managers, measured the performance of managers every Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 7 quarter and compared it to other managers, and developed guidelines and objectives to document what was expected of a manager and how he was expected to do it. Boardmember Sharpless commented that an administrator was needed as an interface between the investment manager and the Board, and also a firm like that of Mr. Palmquist was needed to keep track of how the investment manager was performing compared to other investment managers. Boardmember Sharpless commented that in the existing setup, Florida League of Cities was the administrator, NationsBank was the bookkeeping custodian, and Atlanta Capital was the investment advisor; and if a change was made someone would be needed to take the place of NationsBank. Mr. Palmquist advised that ,if the Board was happy with NationsBank and Atlanta Capital that probably separate arrangements could bey , , made with both of them to continue. Chairman Mackail commented that one 'of the goals of the Board was never to be in an unfunded balance position, and expressed his opinion that this was an area that should be concentrated upon. Mr. Palmquist responded that some items were outside the control of the Board, and gave an example of a firefighters' union negotiating with the Village to change benefits, which would be out of the Board' s hands. Mr. Palmquist stated that the Board' s job was to run the plan given to them by the Village. Village Manager Bradford summarized direction to Finance Director Kascavelis: 1. Look into financial aspects of the equation a) Obtain a list of names of companies to contact b) Investigate with Atlanta Capital and NationsBank whether they would allow the Village to continue an indirect relationship such as their present direct relationship. c) Check with banks with offices located within the Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 8 village to see if they could provide services, as well as Sun Trust. Ask for their fees in writing. d) Check to see if a letter of determination had been filed. Mr. Palmquist cautioned that the Village should not be alarmed if no letter existed. Mr. Palmquist explained that if an actuarial report was desired only every other year that the year of the report his company' s fees would be slightly more than the , proposed $2, 800 and the year a report Jwas not done the cost would be down into the hundreds, adding the two years together a two-year cycle of fees might be approximately $3, 500 as compared to the $5, 600 proposed with an annual report. The Board thanked Mr. Palmquist and assured him they would be in touch. VII. STATUS REPORT ON FIREFIGHTERS PENSION TRUST FUND (Bill Kascavelis, Director of Finance) - Chairman Mackail left the meeting at 9:40 A.M. Secretary of the Board Bradford served in the Chairman' s absence. A) Financial Report (NationsBank Trust) Bill C. Kascavelis, Finance Director, presented the status report on changes in finances since the last meeting for February and March, 1996, and stated that as of 3/31/96 the total assets of the Fund were $294,439.46. Boardmember Sharpless made a motion to accept the Financial Report for February and lurch, 1996. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Tom Bradford - for • Bill Sharpless for Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 9- Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. B. Report of Contributions (Employees/Employer) (March, April, and May 1996) Finance Director Kascavelis commented that reports had been distributed to the Boardmembers for March, April, and May total contributions. The date of firefighter Flint' s separation was discussed, which Mr. Kascavelis explained had been in the prior quarter. Boardmember Trube questioned that firefighter Halliday' s resignation was not reflected in the reports. -The response was that hisseparation date would be Jthie 1, therefore the next quarter's reports would contain that information. There were no employee changes for the current quarter. Boardmember Thurman made a motion to accept the Financial Report. Boardmember Trube seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Tom; Bradford - for Bill Sharpleas - for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. C. Employee Changes Finance Director Kascavelis reported that there were no employee changes for the quarter. Boardmember Trube made a motion to accept the Employee Report. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 10 on the motion was: Tom Bradford - for Bill Sharpless - for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. D. Atlanta Capital's Quarterly Review of the Florida Municipal Pension Trust Fund as of March 31, 1996. (1) Review by Boardmember William Sharpless, Esq. Boardmember Sharpless reviewed Atlanta Capital' s Quarterly Reliew of the Florida Municipal Pension Trust Fund. Investment Returns were reviewed as of 3/31/96. Boardmember Sharpless commented that the total fund was up 1-.3% for the quarter, the return on fixed income was down 2.1% and the equity was up 4. 9% . The Lehman Intermediate G/C Aggregate was down 1.8%, the Lehman G/C High Quality Interest Aggregate' was down 0.7%, the S&P 500 Index was up 5 . 4%, so that Atlanta Capital was a little below the index with which they compared themselves, however the performance was not bad. Mr. Sharpless indicated that their primary objectives were to seek long-term growth of capital and income consistent with conservation of capital; necessary liquidity would be maintained to meet payout requirements, emphasis was placed on achieving consistent returns and avoiding extreme volatility in market value. Investment guidelines given to them by Florida League of Cities were that the kinds of equities the Florida Municipal Pension Trust Fund invested in were capital investments, consumer goods, interest sensitive stocks, and intermediate goods and services, and they did not • Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 11 invest in areas such as utilities, energy, and oil, and were only in 39 companies at the present time. Their instructions from the Florida League of Cities were that they should have no more than 551 equities. Mr. Sharpless analyzed the quarterly review, stating their investment objective was the same as for the previous ;quarter- -high quality stocks and bonds with a maximum exposure to stocks of 55%. Their outlook' on the economy was for modest GDP growth at 2 . 0%, down from 2.41 in the previous quarter; inflation steady at 2.5%, up from 2.4%, long-term interest rates declining slightly„ the same as for the previous quarter; the yield curve steepening; earnings , rowth sluggish, changed from \ slowing; and stocks held 'fully valued, changed from . reasonably valued during the past quarter; bonds attractive, which was unchanged; and their strategy was to remain fully invested, with sector emphasis on health care, which was new; company focus was to be steady for improving margins, which was changed from looking for improving margins. Other strategies were unchanged. Their forecast included S&P 500 earnings per share would be 36, down from the last quarter' s 38.25. S&P 500 dividends were projected lower than the previous quarter, with interest rates on 5-year treasuries and 30-year bonds to be up slightly and the S&P 500 Index to be up to 6.60 in one year. Basically, the stock market was expected to be fairly sluggish. Their equity investment philosophy was the same as before. Very few changes had been made in \;the portfolio: One stock, Loral, had been deleted in the capital investment section, and one, Vandag, in . the consumer goods section. A new stock had been purchased, Interpublic. More Colgate Palmolive stock had been \added and also Intel. Mr. Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 12 Sharpless commented he would like to see more stocks in more sectors to provide better diversification; however, their strategy was to only go into the sectors they liked. Mr. Sharpless commented their outlook on the economy had gone down slightly since the last quarter. Their estimate for the Consumer Price Index was that it would go down slightly over a one-year period. Boardmember Sharpless made a motion to accept the Atlanta Capital Quarterly Review Report. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Tom Bradford - for Bill Sharpless - - for Shawn Thurman C for , James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. , R. Actuarial Valuation Report for FY 1995/96 (Murray B. Cohen, Ph.D. ABA, NSPA, BA, Boggs i Associates, Pension Consultants) Finance Director reviewed highlights of the annual actuarial valuation report and explained that calculations were made following guidelines and using mortality standards. Mr. Kascavelis reviewed the payroll for 10/1/94 of 21.8% against the 10/1/95 figure of 20.7%. Mr. Kascavelis explained that the Village was over providing to the fund at the present time and that a surplus had been created. Boardmember Bradford questioned the amount estimated_ _for. --minimum city contribution, which Mr. Kascavelis verified must be between 6.7% and 7.2%, and which was approximately a 50% reduction from the present 14.4% contribution. During discussion of possibly reducing the contribution, Mr. Kascavelis expressed his opinion that the Village Council Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 13 would desire a recommendation from this Board. Attorney Hawkins verified that the issue would be whether the Village was in compliance with the ordinance, and that this would be an issue for the Village Council. Boardmember Bradford questioned whether the-report was saying the contribution could be a minimum of 7.2% and - meet plan requirements. Finance Director Kascavelis responded that according to the assumptions of the actuary, if the minimum were contributed during this fiscal year, by the end of the fiscal year the surplus would be reduced to the point that it would' be even. Boardmember Sharpless recommended that the actuary be invited to a meeting to answer questions regarding the report. Mr. Kascavelis made a note to request Mr. Boggs to come to a meeting'. Boardmember Sharpless pointed out that at a meeting in Tallahassee it was stressed that every Boardmember had one purpose which was the beet interests of the firefighters, and that whether it was costing the Village more or less money was not to be considered. Boardmember Trube commented that the firefighters did not wish to overburden the Village, and expressed the opinion that-further research was needed before proceeding. Boardmember Sharpless questioned,what kind of recommendations this Board should make to the Village Council if called upon. Mr. Kascavelis questioned whether a special meeting was desired or whether a letter would. suffice. Boardmember. Bradford favored an answer on this issue as soon as possible, and stated that a letter would probably suffice. A poll of the Board indicated that the Boardmembers favored a special meeting rather than to wait until the next quarterly meeting. Mr. Kascavelis summarized the report, and commented that the bottom line was that a surplus had been accrued. Fire Chief Weinand questioned whether if the contribution ' were changed to 7.2%, if the rate would go back up when the surplus was gone, to which Mr. Kascavelis responded • Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 14 - he did not know if the change would be permanent. Fire Chief Weinand recommended that the rate be proportional between the Village and employee. Councilmember Mike Meder, who was present in the audience, requested 7.2% be translated into a dollar figure, which was estimated to be approximately a $35, 000 reduction. Discussion ensued regarding approving the report when there were items that Boardmembers did not understand. It was determined that acknowledgment of receipt of the report should be made by authorizing payment. Boardmember Bradford recommended that the report be accepted and a request be made for a supplemental report to explain issues which had arisen. Boardmember Trubl made a motion to accept the Actuarial Valuation Report and to authorize payment for the report. Boardmember Sharpless seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: Tom Bradford- - for Bill Sharpless - for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted. VIII. TEQUESTA MUNICIPAL FIREFIGHTERS PENSION TRUST FUND, SUMMARY PLAN DESCRIPTION PREPARED BY MEMBER THOSE G. BRADFORD. A) Review Boardmember Bradford explained that Florida Statute 112 . 66 required a summary plan to be updated every two years and distributed to all new hires when employed. Mr. Bradford explained he had updated the summary plan Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 15 with updated zip code, etc. , and would now need to insert Mr. Trube' s name as a Boardmember. Mr. Bradford suggested the updated summary plan also be distributed to all present employees. B) Recommendations Boardmember Sharpless made a motion to approve the summary plan with the addition of Kr. Trube's- name and address to Exhibit A and request that the Villag e distribute the summary to all existing employees and to all future hires in the hiring process. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote on the motion was: , Tom Bradford - for Bill Sharpless - for Shawn Thurman - for James Trube - for the motion was therefore passed and adopted: IX. ANY OTHER NATTERS Boardmember Bradford reminded the Board that at the last meeting he had discussed a proposed merger of employee retirement plans so that they would be under one Board. Boardmember Bradford explained that this matter was not on the agenda since it was a legislative matter requiring Village Council decision, however, he was providing the new plan to the Boardmembers so that they could study it, share the same with the other. Firefighters, and offer feedback prior to the pending adoption of the same. Boardmember Bradford explained that there would be specific plan requirements for each of three categories of employees: general employees, firefighters, and police; and funds for each category would be kept separate, however one Board Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 16 would administer all employees. Boardmember Bradford commented that the Town of Palm Beach was under such an arrangement, and seemed to be happywith it. Discussion ensued regarding funds, with -the consensus that they should not be commingled within one fund. Mr. Kascavelis stated that individual funds would be set up for each employee category, with individual annual reports as well as a consolidated report including all three funds. Boardmember Sharpless questioned whether anything had ever been done towards appointing 'a medical board for the plan. Mr. Kascavelis reported literature had been received from South Miami where a medical board had been established for reviewing disability cases. Boardmember Sharpless recommended that a medical board be established. Mr. Kascavelis agreed-that he would assemb a information for the Board. Boardmember. Trube requested that Board meetings be scheduled for a predetermined date so that firefighters would have sufficient time to arrange their schedules to be able to attend, and explained that many complaints had been received that not enough notice was given for meetings. Boardmember Trube also requested that sufficient notice of special meetings and workshop meetings be provided. Boardmember Bradford requested that Mr. Kascavelis schedule this matter as an agenda item for the next meeting of the Board. Boardmember Sharpless requested that the quarterly meeting be scheduled closer to the end of the quarter or the date reports were received from Florida League of Cities. Wade Griest commented that from his experience with corporate pensions, the company he had worked\for had found that providing employees with annual updates to keep them informed of their pension plan benefits was a morale booster and was very important. - Mr. Griest also recommended exit interviews. \ During ensuing \ discussion, Boardmember Sharpless suggested that in the event the Village chose to . Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 - ` Page 17 hire Mr. Paimquist' s firm, that individual statements could be provided in-house for the year that the firm did not provide them. Mr. Kascavelis reported he had received a letter from Florida League of Cities which he would distribute along with information received from Mr. Cohen. He also reported he had received notice that the annual report for the last fiscal year had been approved by the State Retirement Division and that insurance premium taxes received this year were $17, 015, an increase of $3, 000 over the previous year. VIII. ADJOURNMENT Boardmember Trube moved that \the meeting be adjOurned. Boardmember Thurman seconded the motion. The vote on the Amotion was: Tom Bradford - for Bill Sharpless - for Shawn Thurmond - for James Trube - for The motion was therefore passed and adopted and the meeting was adjourned at 10:45 A.M. Respectfully submitted, C7L.,<A2) Betty Laur Recording Secretary Firefighters Pension Trust Fund Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes June 7, 1996 Page 18 ATTEST: Joann Manganiello Village Clerk DATE APPROVED: • • 1 VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA FIREFIGHTERS PENSION FUND Proposal by Gabriel, Roeder, Smith and Company to Provide Actuarial and Consulting Services June 7, 1996 Services • • Annual Actuarial Valuation Report • Individual Benefit Statement for each participant • Calculation of Benefits for any person who leaves the Plan and is eligible for a benefit • Determine Actuarial Impact for up to two possible changes in Plan - -Benefits • Up to two meetings with the Board Fees • $2,800 per year for Services listed above for two years ♦ - Hourly rates for any other-services not included above GRS Facts • Employee-owned company with about 110 employees in seven offices • About 500 governmental plans in 32 states are GRS clients, including 30 statewide systems • About_110 governmental plans in Florida are GRS clients.