HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes_Regular_03/09/2006MINUTES
VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA
REGULAR VILLAGE COUNCIL MEETING
THURSDAY, MARCH 9, 2006
I. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
The meeting was called to order by Mayor Jim Humpage at 7:08 P.M. A roll call
was taken by Village Clerk Gwen Carlisle. Present were: Mayor Jim Humpage,
Vice Mayor Pat Watkins, Council Member Geraldine A. Genco, and Council
Member Tom Paterno. Also in attendance were: Village Manager Michael R.
Couzzo, Jr., Village Clerk Gwen Carlisle, and Department Heads. Village
Attorney Scott Hawkins arrived at 7:10 P.M.
II. INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Mayor Humpage gave the invocation and led in the pledge of allegiance to the
flag.
III. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve the agenda; seconded by Council
Member Paterno; motion passed 4-0.
• i m removed from the
Council Member Genco asked if they could address the to s
Consent Agenda.
Council Member Genco removed Item 4 from the Consent Agenda.
Council Member Paterno removed Item 5 from the Consent Agenda.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve the agenda as amended; seconded
by Council Member Genco; motion passed 4-0.
IV. PRESENTATIONS AND PROCLAMATIONS
1. Presentation -Northern Palm Beaches Cultural Alliance - Mr. Roger
Buckwalter
Mr. Roger Buckwalter, Chairman of the Northern Palm Beaches Cultural
Alliance, and 27 year resident of Tequesta, mentioned he has been
devoting a great deal of time to volunteer work much of it involving our
local cultural sector since his retirement in 2001 from the Jupiter Courier.
He highlighted the involvement, goals and events of the Alliance, noting
that the group was formed in June 2004. He felt it was a significant
development for the local cultural community. He indicated currently they
have 19 members, which include Lighthouse Center for the Arts, Blowing
Rocks Music Festival, Maltz Jupiter Theater, Loxahatchee River
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 2
Historical Society, FAU Jupiter Campus, and many others. He mentioned
they have also received encouragement of their work from PB County
Cultural Council, PB County Tourism Development Council, and PB
County Commissioner Karen Marcus. He pointed out the very diverse
group recognizes how much the cultural groups have in common, that they
aze allies, while they are separate and distinct groups. He indicated they
have a shazed overwriting interest to enrich our cultural quality of life.
He mentioned their next meeting would be Friday, March 31, 2006, at
10:00am at the FAU Jupiter Campus. He invited everyone to attend. He
read the mission statement for the group, which summarizes what they do.
He indicated their main effort at this time was to raise the profile of the
local cultural community by mazketing the local cultural groups and
increase their audiences. He pointed out the cultural guide, which Council
received in their packets. He announced they would have a bus tour of the
local cultural sites on March 24, 2006 from the Lighthouse Center of the
Arts. He mentioned they held a benefit performance last Mazch at the
Jupiter High School to aid two members, Loxahatchee River Historical
Society and Busch Wildlife Center which sufferedery heavy damage in the
two 2004 hurricanes. He commented he felt this collaboration is good for
the community, and thinks it is good for Tequesta where the cultural life is
so important to the residents. He explained the key to this alliance is
establishing a broad base of support, especially for those outside the
cultural community, from other institutions such as businesses,
government, etc. He asked Council to look favorably on the Alliance and
asked that they join in as a member.
Mayor Humpage asked Council to consider at the next Council Meeting
placing this item on the agenda to support the Cultural Alliance. He
mentioned the Village has increased their ability to charitable donations.
He felt it was a worthy cause. Vice Mayor Watkins asked if this was going
to be for the membership in the Alliance. Mr. Buckwalter commented the
membership is $100.00 per yeaz for government, businesses, and
institutions, and $50.00 for individuals.
Mayor Humpage asked Attorney Hawkins if Council chose to act on this
item this evening, could they do it under this Presentation. Attorney
Hawkins recommended placing it on the next agenda to get public input.
Consensus of Council agreed to place it on the April Regular Council
Meeting agenda.
2. Proclamation declaring the Month of April 2006 as "Read Together Palm
Beach County Month.
Attorney Hawkins read for the record the Proclamation declaring the
• Month of April 2006 as "Read Together Palm Beach County Month.
2
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 3
V. STANDING REPORTS
VILLAGE ATTORNEY
1St Baptist Church of Tequesta - He mentioned his firm has performed vanous
reseazch related issues over the last month, and commented there was one issue he
wanted to bring to Council's attention. He indicated the pastor of the Baptist
Church had contacted one of his colleagues, and asked with respect to a zoning
issue. He mentioned he has brought this to the attention of Village Manager
Couzzo and Ms. Catherine Hazding, Director of Community Development, and
they have advised that he can proceed in an informal matter. He indicated he was
mentioning this to Council so they were aware, and if he perceived any issue,
whatsoever, regazding a potential conflict, he would bring that to Council's
attention, and direct his colleagues to discontinue. He wanted Council to be
aware, because it has surfaced in the last two weeks, and has to do with a Special
Exception request.
Council Member Genco suggested Pastor Paul may have called everyone on
Council to ask if they would object to him petitioning for the change. She noted
the pastor called her, and she told him to see Ms. Hazding, and that the zoning
regulations needed to be addressed by way of the code. Mayor Humpage
indicated Pastor Paul Beresford also called him, and he told him he had to follow
the rules. Vice Mayor Watkins felt he probably received that same message from
all Council Members.
VILLAGE MANAGER -None
VI. CONSENT AGENDA
All items listed under Consent Agenda are considered routine and will be enacted
by one motion. There will be no separate discussion of these items unless a
Village Council Member so requests, in which event the item will be removed
from the Consent Agenda and considered in its normal sequence on the Agenda.
Council Member Genco removed Item 4 from the Consent Agenda.
Council Member Paterno removed Item 5 from the Consent Agenda.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve the Consent Agenda, as amended;
seconded by Council Member Genco; motion passed 4-0.
Therefore the following items were approved on the Consent Agenda.
3. Ms. Catherine Hazding, Director of Community Development as Village
representative to the Loxahatchee Coordinating Council.
6. Council approval for Amendment No. 1 to the Lease Agreement with
Nextel South Corporation.
•
END OF CONSENT AGENDA
3
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 4
ITEMS REMOVED FROM THE CONSENT AGENDA
4. RESOLUTION 13-05/06 - A Resolution of the Village Council of the
Village of Tequesta, Palm Beach County, Florida, Awarding a Contract to
Atlantic Truck Center, of Ft. Lauderdale, Florida for the amount of
$45,639.00 for the purchase of a Ford F650 Dump Truck, with funding
coming from the Stormwater #403-250-664.600 and Water Fund #401-
411-664.600 and authorizing the Village Manager to execute the
applicable contract on behalf of the Village.
Council Member Genco mentioned the Village already has one dump
truck although it is not the same type of truck, and 1 front-end loader, 2
backhoes, and one Bobcat. She felt there were only two people that the
Village would look at utilizing the equipment. She commented she
understands that getting this equipment is in preparation of hiring people
to do landscaping and maintenance. She pointed out since the Village does
not have the Staff designated to operate the equipment; she indicated she
would agree in principal to endorse it; but it would be subject to having
the Staff prior to spending the money. She explained it does not make
sense to have 7 cars in a garage for a two household family. She felt this is
a very similar situation, and knows that the Village plans are to beef up the
maintenance, and at that point in time then this equipment would be
appropriate. She noted the Village does not have the people unless they
are going to ask the administrative people to operate it. She felt they
should not be asked, because it is not in their job description, and not their
responsibility.
Mayor Humpage pointed out this was an item that had been approved in
the 2004/2005 budget. He mentioned Council approved the dump truck in
the previous budget year. Council Member Genco felt it was not approved
specifically as an item. She mentioned Council had discussion about the
truck and it was subject to the fact that the Village would be hiring people
to utilize it. She explained she distinctly recalls that discussion, because
she was the one that brought it up. She stated the Village Manager had
said to them at that Council meeting this was in preparation of the Village
having their own staff to do the maintenance. She pointed out the Village
has not hired the staff and questioned why it is being purchased at this
time. Mayor Humpage reiterated it was an item approved in the budget
last year, but it did not pass the first time, so now it is back before Council
again for a couple of reasons. He explained in his business he has 20
pieces of equipment and only 5 employees. He pointed out it is the
equipment and the nature of when it is needed. He felt it was necessary
equipment to make the job go better.
•
4
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 5
Mayor Humpage felt Council missed the opportunity by not purchasing
this dump truck prior to Hurricane Wilma, when Public Works had to go
out and pick up debris when Waste Management shut down. He indicated
he was out with Staff, including Mr. Russell White, Public Services
Manager and Public Works staff and they made 10 unnecessary trips
because the flatbed, even with the rails, could not handle the amount of
debris. He suggested this is an excellent idea, and it is at the right price.
He asked if it was at the same price as it was last yeaz. Mr. White
commented it was.
Mayor Humpage explained one of the things that this Council is always
looking to do is to better prepare themselves in the event of a hurricane.
He stated they aze only 3 months away from hurricane season. He noted if
the Village has trees down in the road such as in Humcane Wilma this
truck, which is about 4 to 5 times the capacity would eliminate many trips
to the landfill. He felt this is something Council should do, and it was in
the budget, and not money Council would have to appropriate from
another fund, and the price is right. He felt it gives the Village one more
tool. He commented Staff could use it to move earth at the new Village
Hall, and save money too. He felt Council should approve it. Vice Mayor
Watkins mentioned she asked the Village Manager to bring this item back
at the last meeting. She indicated this was an item in the budget and that
Council had approved it. She explained Mr. White has consistently come
to Council with cost savings in his department for the yeazs she has been
involved m Council, and felt he would not have suggested something that
he did not need, or did not have a use for. She stated she trusts him to
know what he needs. She pointed out Council is constantly asking Staff to
do more and more, and going towazd doing more things on their own. She
believes there will be more opportunities, in addition to the one the Mayor
mentioned, that Staff could have used the truck. She stated she supports
the purchase, and felt it would end up paying for itself in a very short span
of time.
Mayor Humpage asked if the dump truck could be used at the Lineaz Pazk.
Village Manager Couzzo felt the project might be completed before the
truck is acquired. Council Member Paterno commented he agreed with
Council Member Genco that he did not want to approve the truck the last
time it came before Council, but since then he has seen firsthand that the
truck would be asset. He mentioned he has witnessed them making many
loads to do something when they could have done it in probably a 1 /3 of
the time. He felt the biggest cost in the Village is the manpower, so
whatever Council can do to make that more efficient it would be a cost
savings to the community, and give the residents better service. He
pointed out there aze a lot more projects coming up in the future, and this
equipment could be very helpful.
5
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 6
Council Member Genco questioned the difference in capacity of the high-
sided dump truck and current low-sided flatbed. Mr. White explained the
current flatbed could hold about 3 yards of material, and the dump truck
could hold 6 yards completely in the bed without having to worry about
things falling out. Council Member Genco pointed out it is about double
the capacity, not many times the capacity. She did not understand that if
the Village does not have Staff why they are buying a lot of equipment.
She stated she is really opposed to the fact the Village is calling in
administrative people who do not have the experience using heavy
equipment to operate it.
Mayor Humpage commented he respected Council Member Genco's
opinion, and mentioned in working with Staff it could be used. Council
Member Genco pointed out Mayor Humpage does not have a million
dollars in equipment. Mayor Humpage noted this item is only $47,000.00.
Council Member Genco pointed out it was 2 trips instead of 1 because it is
double the capacity. Mr. White confirmed it is double the capacity
depending on materials. Council Member Genco explained because there
is money in the budget does not mean you have to spend it. Mayor
Humpage agreed, but felt this was part of the Village's hurricane
preparedness.
Council Member Genco questioned the Village's liability if someone not
qualified to operate the vehicle goes out and hits someone. Village
Manager Couzzo stated the Village would not have any people in the
vehicles that are not certified to drive them, nor have the appropriate
license. Council Member Genco asked what if she wanted to drive the
vehicle. Village Manager Couzzo stated she would not be allowed to do
that. He pointed out someone must have the proper type of license to
operate certain types of trucks. Council Member Genco felt the driver did
not need any special license for this type of truck. Mr. White agreed this
dump truck does not require a CDL license, and most of the employees
can drive them. Council Member Genco stated she would love to learn to
drive a CAT. Vice Mayor Watkins asked if Council Members were
driving the trucks. Mayor Humpage clarified he did not drive a Village
truck; he followed them around in his personal vehicle, and threw the
debris into the truck.
Council Member Genco agreed Mr. White is an incredible employee, and
she does not question him or second-guess him, but noted she looks at
staffing, and what our equipment is, and the utilization of it. She pointed
out for someone to make five trips over a few months, instead of one trip,
is not a cost savings to spend $50,000.00. She explained if the Village was
going to have Staff to utilize this on a weekly basis, or a consistent basis
she would be all for it, but the Village does not have the staff at this time.
6
Minutes -Village Council Regulaz Meeting 03/09/06
Page 7
Mayor Humpage asked Attorney Hawkins to read the Resolution.
Attorney Hawkins read for the record the title of Resolution 13-05/06.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve Resolution 13-05/06; seconded by
Council Member Paterno; motion passed 3-1, with Council Member Genco dissenting.
5. RESOLUTION 62-05/06 - A Resolution of the Village Council of the
Village of Tequesta, Palm Beach County, Florida, Approving a proposal
from Terracon Services, Inc. for Landscaping and Irrigation of Tequesta
Linear Park in the Amount of $79,358.50 (Account #303-399-663.675).
Council Member Paterno asked for additional information on the location
of the plantings. Mr. Robert Garlo, Assistant Village Manager mentioned
the original design of the FEC Beautification Project/Lineaz Park, was
done by Roy-Fisher and Associates. He indicated the bid specifications for
this agenda item was taken from the plans, and given out to the companies
listed in his memo. He apologized if the numbers were confusing, noting
the Village received landscaping bids and imgation bids sepazately, and
when Staff put them together, from three companies, Terracon was the
lowest bid. He asked Council to consider approving the bid awazd to
Terracon Services, Inc.
Ms. Connie Roy-Fisher, Landscape Architect mentioned the Pazk design
was before Council about a yeaz ago, which included the path, some
bermmg, sabal palm trees, specialty plantings and kiosks. She explamed at
that time they were asking Council for approval for a Palm Beaches
Beautification grant, which the Village applied for, and received funding.
She indicated that was to pay for Phase I landscaping, which is the
berming, the sabal and thatch palms, and some sod. She pointed out that is
what will be installed now, with the idea there will be future phases.
Council Member Paterno questioned how many more phases are planned
to complete the project. Ms. Roy-Fisher explained it depended on budgets,
and grant applications. Council Member Paterno asked how much more
would the project cost. Assistant Manager Gazlo indicated the funding that
was granted in two increments from the County and the beautification
grant exists through the calendaz yeaz. He mentioned the engineering and
the mast arms signalization has held up some of the work done at the
intersection. He explained what they are doing with the existing funding is
the Linear Pazk, and bringing it south towazd the intersection, without
interfering with the construction of the mast arms when they go in. He
indicated all the funding was coming from a Capital Project account.
Mayor Humpage asked what the Village had expended so far of the
$358,000. Assistant Manager Gazlo pointed out the $358,000 was the
revenue.
7
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 8
He mentioned $338,000 was given by Commissioner Kazen Marcus from
her discretionary funds in two amounts: $200,000, and $135,000 plus the
beautification grant of $23,000 that was approved at the last Council
Meeting, totaling $358,000. He noted when the original $200,000 was
given to the Village; Council did a matching grant of $200,000. He noted
the total amount of the project is $558,000. He mentioned what has been
expended to date, not including this bid awazd, is approximately $160,000
to $170,000. He noted the costs have been for the path, engineering costs
associated with the mast arms, and Staff labor costs at a significantly
lower amount than if the Village was to contract the work out. Mayor
Humpage noted the Village is approximately at $248,000 including this
project. Mr. Garlo agreed. He explained the number he does not have at
this time is the mast arms. He mentioned the County just entered into a
contract with a new bidder. He pointed out the original number for the
mast arm signalization came in at $200,000, but it could be different now.
He indicated he should be getting the new number within two months,
because as soon as the engineering is at 100%, the County will put out a
bid, and the Village could piggy-back their contract.
Vice Mayor Watkins indicated it was nice to see the project started, since
everyone had been waiting for something to happen. She mentioned just
cleaning out the trash, and starting the pathway has been a great
improvement. She commented she was glad to see that it was done in-
house since it saved the Village some money. Mr. Gazlo indicated people
aze already using the path. Council Member Paterno felt the remaining
$260,000 was basically to cover the mast arms, and any money left it
would be used for landscaping. Mr. Gazlo agreed. Council Member
Paterno thanked Mr. Garlo for a great job on the work and clean up, and
felt once the trees are in people are going to be surprised how beautiful the
azea will be, and that it will be used to roller skate and walk the path.
Mayor Humpage pointed out that the difference in the numbers were with
the irrigation and landscaping. He noted the Village has already confirmed
with Terracon that the irrigation is anon-issue, and that the Village can
move forward at the cost provided in their bid. Mr. Gazlo indicated he
spoke with them regazding the dispazity in the numbers, and that is their
bid. He noted if Council awazds the bid, they will start the project, and
they will be held to their figure.
Council Member Genco asked for clarification on the irrigation. Mayor
Humpage noted the only company that provided the Village with irrigation
in their proposal was Terracon. He commented both Rood and Aiello was
absent of the irrigation system. He mentioned their numbers were
somewhat similaz but lower than Terracon, since Terracon included the
irrigation. Mayor Humpage pointed out he wanted them to understand if
Council approved this bid, it would include the imgation. Council
Member Genco mentioned Terracon has the $15,800 for irrigation.
8
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 9
Mayor Humpage noted there is a $31,000 disparity between the others and
Terracon. Council Member Genco indicated the Village is going with
what they feel is the lowest and best bid. Council Member Paterno asked
when the anticipated completion date was for this work. Mr. Garlo
indicated the project was starting immediately. Council Member Paterno
asked whether the project would be finished in 30 days. Assistant Manager
Garlo indicated the irrigation also needed to be installed. Ms. Roy-Fisher
mentioned she had not talked to them about their schedule, but suggested
giving them two months. Mayor Humpage felt the irrigation needed to go
in before the shrubs were planted. Council Member Genco commented
this was just the first phase of the plantings, and there would be another
phase for plantings. She indicated these were the larger planting materials,
and the smaller flowering and accent pieces will be coming in at another
time in the budget. Council Member Paterno agreed, and confirmed that
would need to be budgeted.
Attorney Hawkins read for the record the title of Resolution 62-05/06.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve Resolution 62-05/06; seconded by
Council Member Paterno; motion passed 4-0.
VII. COMMiJNICATIONS FROM CITIZENS
- Mr. Basil Dalack, resident of Golfview Drive and incoming Council Member
mentioned the 3`d anmversary of the Iraq War is coming up next week. He
indicated he was thinking of ways to commemorate the horrible event. He
proposed a couple of suggestions: 1) All houses of Worship starting this weekend
and next weekend, consider starting and fighting the Iraq War with our notion of
morality; 2) Council consider a Resolution, that he will submit next week when he
takes office. He commented he will give the original to the Clerk, but will
distribute it so every Council Member has a copy in advance. He asked that the
Resolution be placed on the next Regular Council Meeting agenda. Mr. Dalack
noted another item he would like placed on the April agenda is consideration to
hold, either the last Thursday of the month, or some other convenient date, a
Meeting, patterned after the New England Town Hall Meetings. He stated this is
where the citizens discuss matters of great public importance. He mentioned that
could be items such as Palm Beach County voting mechanisms, etc. He indicated
he has attended several meeting at the Supervisor of Elections office, and felt the
Palm Beach County voting machines are deplorable.
Mayor Humpage clarified with Mr. Dalack the following items for the April 13,
2006 Regular Council agenda: 1) Council consider having Town Hall Meetings.
Mr. Dalack responded yes, and suggested once a month; and 2) Offer a
Resolution to Council for its approval. Mr. Dalack stated he would read only the
title of the Resolution for the record.
9
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 10
Mayor Humpage mentioned he did not have a problem with the Town Hall
Meetings if Council wanted to consider the item. He stated he believes every
American citizen has the right to vote in the National elections. He noted he did
not know if he wanted to entertain the thought of getting into a major political
statement. He mentioned he would not be comfortable with the Resolution. Mr.
Dalack suggested Council discuss it next week. Vice Mayor Watkins stated she
did not want to discuss it. Mayor Humpage stressed he did not want to discuss,
and that Mr. Dalack would need a consensus of Council to put that on the agenda.
Council Member Paterno agreed with the Mayor. Mayor Humpage reiterated he
did not want to make a political statement, and stated that it is the right of every
citizen in the room, and every resident in the Village of Tequesta, and it should be
exercised at the poll, or other venues of our Congressmen or Senators. He
mentioned he would support Town Hall Meetings, but would not support the
second item. Mr. Dalack mentioned Council did not need to do it this evening.
Mayor Humpage stated he did not want it on the agenda. Mr. Dalack stated he
read the Village Charter, and Resolutions and Ordinances are adopted pursuant to
Florida Statute Chapter 166. He indicated he did not see any requirement that
there be approval of Council beforehand for a Resolution. Vice Mayor Watkins
stated it takes a consensus of Council to place something on the agenda. Village
Manager Couzzo explained it is a policy of Council to determine what item goes
on the agenda. Mayor Humpage agreed and stated the item would have to have a
consensus of Council to place it on the next agenda. Mr. Dalack asked Council to
consider placing it on the next agenda.
Attorney Hawkins stated there would need to be a consensus of Council, so
Council would need a showing. Vice Mayor Watkins stated she was opposed to
placing it on the agenda. Mayor Humpage stated he would support Town Hall
meetings on the agenda, but would not support the Resolution Mr. Dalack wanted
to place on the agenda. Council Member Paterno indicated he totally agreed with
the Mayor. He mentioned he was taken back by the Resolution. Mr. Dalack
pointed out there are 170 municipalities in the United States that passed
Resolutions against the war, before the waz, and 75 municipalities that have
passed Resolutions since the war began. Mayor Humpage stated that is their right.
Vice Mayor Watkins stated she did not mind discussing Town Hall meetings, but
she did not want to see that Resolution on the agenda. Council Member Genco
stated the way Council has been established; Council Members aze non-partisan.
Mayor Humpage agreed they aze not republicans, democrats or independents.
Council Member Genco stated that is only one part of the issue, however, Mr.
Dalack mentioned something about a Florida Statute. She indicated she would
like to know more about it, as faz as, whether or not the Council's policy of
requiring approval by the Council to put something on the agenda complies with
Florida Statutes. She stated she is interested in knowing that, because she feels
that is the larger issue. She felt the Council policy does not have the right to
conflict with or override the Florida Statute.
i
10
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/Ob
Page 11
Council Member Genco indicated once she had that answer then she would know
how she felt about placing the item on the agenda. She stated Council is a non-
partisan platform, and subject to fording out whether any one of Council could
place a Resolution on the agenda, she would have to reserve her opinion. Attorney
Hawkins stated he could not answer the question as to whether or not the policy
would conflict with the Florida Statute. He suggested he would reseazch the issue,
and if it is determined that the policy does conflict then Council could place it on
the agenda, and deal with it at the April Meeting. He stated if the research
concludes, and he will report it to the Village Manager, that the Village policy in
compliance with the Statute then their action as of this evening would stand.
Council Member Paterno agreed if that is what the State Statute is Council would
need to put in on the agenda. Attorney Hawkins stated absolutely, and then
Council would address their views at that session. He noted Council Member
Genco's comments are well taken, but he is not sure of what the statute requires.
He stated he did not think the Village conflicted, but he would look into it.
Consensus of Council agreed to place the subject of Town Hall Meetings on the
April agenda, and have Attorney Hawkins determine whether Council is in
compliance with the State Statute; then give Mr. Dalack that information, and if
the Village is in compliance, then it is the consensus to not place the item on the
agenda. Council Member Genco noted it was her opinion to not place it on the
agenda, mainly because of the non-partisan requirement. Consensus of Council
agreed.
- Mr. Joe Baker, resident of Fairview East and 30 year resident mentioned he had
concerns with Code Enforcement of items in people's yazds, whether it be boats,
trailers, or sheds, etc. He stated he had a code enforcement officer at his house the
other day, and it appears in terms of height, how high can a boat or shed can be.
He explained the Code Enforcement Officer told him there was no definition on
the height. He felt it had to be addressed somehow. Mayor Humpage asked if he
was speaking about the height of the boat or shed, or the shielding of those items.
Mr. Baker commented he was talking about if someone has a boat, shed or caz
that it needs to be shielded on three sides. He felt if it goes above the shielding it
would be in violation. He asked what is the definition of how high that shielding
is. He commented there are a number of boats in the Country Club, and he has
had one over the years, and his has always been below the fence or in his garage.
He stated he has seen a number of boats over the years where they protrude quite
a ways above the fence, or they are not covered at all. He indicated his neighbor
has a boat that is shielded with a 5 foot fence, but the boat sticks up 10 or 12 feet,
and is probably to big to launch at the community boat dock. He asked Council to
advertise the meeting in the newspaper so the public could attend. Mayor
Humpage indicated there has been discussion on this topic prior to this evening.
He mentioned Council has not made any decisions, and hopefully the Village will
have workshops on the issue.
f
11
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 12
Mayor Humpage explained the height for fencing is 6 feet. Ms. Catherine
Harding, Community Development Director agreed the maximum height for
fencing is 6 feet. Mayor Humpage pointed out Council is trying to address the
issue, and trying to make people happy, not angry. Council Member Genco
explained they have had the same issue brought up many times during the last
year. She mentioned the Village is in the process of doing a draft ordinance to
revise the code. She pointed out the Village was looking for some citizens that
were willing to give input on the preliminary draft. She mentioned Mr. Baker's
point is being addressed, but may not be addressed as quickly as he wants.
Police Chief Steve Allison commented the Police Department for many years
interpreted the Ordinance the way Mr. Baker interpreted the ordinance. He noted
they made a test case a few years back and the Special Master throw it out, and
the ordinance was unenforceable as written for the tuna towers sticking out above
the roof. He felt the ordinance needed to be fixed, and the intent was that the boat
should not be seen with the screening. He stated the Special Master disagreed
with the Police Department. Council Member Genco stated the rule does not
specify what exactly it needs to specify. Vice Mayor Watkins explained the boat
issue was one of Council's top priorities for a Workshop. She noted Council
wanted to make sure the notice went out so the public could participate. Council
Member Genco asked for the status of the workshop. Vice Mayor Watkins
commented Council was waiting until Mr. Dalack was seated on Council, and
then set the date. She questioned whether it would be a good idea, since the
boating issue is primarily focused on the Country Club, to have the Country Club
come forward with ideas, and have their association get together. She felt that
would help the Village along. Mr. Baker mentioned the Tequesta Country Club
Association (TCCA) discussed it at their last meeting. He pointed out TCCA has a
committee member that has been appointed the liaison to the Village, and they are
going get with Staff regarding the issue. Mayor Humpage indicated the Village
would be interested in getting a copy of the TCCA meeting minutes. Council
Member Genco asked if the Board's restrictions were more specific than the
Village's rules.
Mr. Bill Becchi, resident of Country Club Drive and TCCA Board member
mentioned he was present as a resident and not representing the Board. He
explained back in November there was a group of boaters before Council, and the
majority of people at the meeting were boaters in the Country Club. He noted they
were concerned about attending the workshops, and giving their input on what
Council was going to do in terms of changing the code, or making the code more
specific so that everyone had a clear idea of what the rules were. He mentioned
the TCCA Board did a survey, and the survey came back 50/50 across the board
for the people that responded. He indicated only 46% responded. He explained the
President of TCCA, Ms. Lori Rogers, who is also an attorney, felt that TCCA
should not say one way or the other, nor form an opinion as a community to bring
that opinion to Council. She felt that it could influence Council one way or the
other.
12
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 13
Vice Mayor Watkins asked if the Board did not get a clear mandate. Mr. Becchi
responded in the affirmative, and indicated the Board told the residents if they
were interested in pursuing the issue, then bring it to Council's attention. He
stated there is no pleasing everyone, so the Board did not want to decide one way
or the other. Council Member Genco asked how many people that live in the
Tequesta Country Club Association are members of TCCA. Mr. Becchi
commented there are 598 homes, and the only way to know if they are members,
are if they pay dues. He indicated about 70%, 362 have paid their dues and are
members. He commented people pay later in the year. Council Member Genco
mentioned when Council hears the opinions of the Association; she wanted to
know approximately how many people TCCA represented in the Village. She
thanked Mr. Beechi for the information. Vice Mayor Watkins noted back in
November and December when Mr. Leslie and others attended the meetings,
Council assured them they would be notified of the Council meetings to discuss
the boat issue.
Council Member Genco asked what the ranking was for the boat issue on the
Workshop schedule. Village Clerk Gwen Carlisle felt the boat issue was ranked
high, but would have to check Council's list. Council Member Genco mentioned
Council had planned to have this workshop with Planning and Zoning Board, and
if the workshop was one of Council's top priority; she suggested have the Village
Clerk go ahead and look at the calendar and schedule the meeting after Mr.
Dalack has taken office, so that Council could have the workshop in April, instead
of waiting another month. Mayor Humpage agreed, because there would be more
residents present. He noted there are other areas besides the Country Club
interested, so if they were to get into an ordinance change, Council would need to
consider everyone.
Consensus of Council agreed to have the clerk schedule a Workshop after April 13, 2006
to discuss the boat issue.
Mr. Beechi mentioned Council could enforce boat restrictions on one side of the
street, but not on the other side of the street. Council Member Genco indicated
that is unincorporated Palm Beach County, and the Village cannot enforce their
codes. She pointed out at a recent Council Meeting Commissioner Marcus agreed
to provide the Village with funds to do Code Enforcement in those areas, and
hopefully Council will be addressing that matter at a future meeting. She pointed
out those areas are so far away from where the County has to come that they do
not get the attention needed. She explained it was noted at the Joint Workshop in
February, Council wanted those areas to be enforced, and Commissioner Marcus
offered the Village some funding to address the code enforcement in those pocket
areas. She stated she hoped that would be on our next Council Meeting agenda.
Mayor Humpage pointed out the codes will not be the same in unincorporated
Palm Beach County. He pointed out if this occurs then the Village would only be
able to enforce the County codes.
I J
13
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 14
Village Manager Couzzo advised Council that he had a meeting scheduled with
Commissioner Marcus this past Monday regarding this issue, and she needed to
postpone it. He advised he would let Council know of the rescheduled meeting.
Mr. Beechi noted the boaters that were present at the previous Council Meetings
did not necessarily represent everyone in the Country Club; they represent their
own interest as boat owners. Mayor Humpage indicated this issue was political
and maybe the answer was to do a referendum, and let the entire community vote.
Council Member Genco commented when the Village does a zoning code change
the public has to vote for it when it is something significant like that. She stated
this could end up being significant. Attorney Hawkins stated the Village would
have to change the zoning ordinance. Mayor Humpage felt a zoning change did
not necessarily need to be done by referendum it could be changed by Council.
Attorney Hawkins agreed, and noted it would have to go to a first and second
notice procedure.
Mayor Humpage stated if this became a volatile issue or an issue of great interest
Council could make it a referendum item. He stated the majority would rule. Mr.
Becchi stated Mr. Doug Fuette, a former President of TCCA is the liaison to the
Village. He commented he is also on the committee and would report back to the
Board. He mentioned the Association takes minutes and he could provide a copy
to Council once they were transcribed. Mayor Humpage commented everyone
will be noticed, and it will be put on the Village website of the meeting date. Mr.
Beechi questioned golf carts on the Country Club Drive bike path. Mayor
Humpage stated that is another issue that Council discussed two meetings ago,
and will be addressed in the future. He stated the Police Department has the
authority to enforce the State Statue, which is no golf carts are allowed on the
pathway, or on public roads. He mentioned Council is trying to come up with an
amiable solution, and that will be another workshop.
VIII. COMMUNICATIONS FROM COUNCIL
COUNCIL MEMBER PATERNO
Tequesta Drive Bridge - He thanked Staff for the hard work, and Council
Members on the efficient and quick action regarding the Tequesta Drive Bridge.
He mentioned he was out at the bridge one day and spoke with the engineer, and
the engineer said this was one of the fastest bridge repairs that he has ever done in
20 years. He stated being only 3 weeks from the day he got the job and start of the
plans, to the completion date. Council Member Paterno felt everyone needed to be
commended for the hard work. He stated also the residents are very happy that it
has been reopened, so that they can go back and forth.
Village Capital Projects - He indicated he was thrilled with the new projects
coming up: Village Hall, Constitution Park, Linear Park, Cypress Drive, the Street
Lighting Program along Tequesta Drive, and the new well and chlorination
system. He mentioned the new chlorination system is changing from gas chlorine
14
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 15
to liquid, which would be safer for the community and the employees who work
at the Plant.
Public Works Department - He wanted to thank Assistant Village Manager and
Director of Public Works Robert Garlo for doing a great job expanding the Public
Works Department. He mentioned between Mr. Garlo and Mr. Russell White,
Public Services Manager they seem to be getting a lot accomplished with very
few people. He felt they were dedicated and hard working employees, and the
Village is very lucky to have these people. Vice Mayor Watkins agreed noting
there are many good things going on in the Village.
VICE MAYOR WATKINS
Education Forum Meeting/JTJB Chamber of Commerce -She mentioned she
attended the meeting this morning, and School Board Superintendent Art Johnson
is calling for public and legislative awareness about the funding for Florida
schools. She explained Florida Schools rank 45th out of 50 states, per person
spending, and that she wanted everyone to be aware so to look for the information
or contact their state legislators. Council Member Genco asked if the School
Board was for or against the voucher program that was recently proposed. Vice
Mayor Watkins commented she could not speak for them, but would assume they
were against it because it pulls funding away. Council Member Genco
commented it would probably provide more funding for our .public schools, if it
did not go through. Vice Mayor Watkins encouraged everyone to read up on it.
COUNCIL MEMBER GENCO
Public Safety Officers Pension Board of Trustees -She explained an issue has
been brought to the Board where the Board has been trying to work with Jupiter
Inlet Colony to allocate funds that are being paid with their Insurance premiums
to the State. She explained a portion of the funds that are paid (when the city pays
their insurance premiums) goes into state pools. She indicated part of that
premium goes into a pocket that benefits firefighters and policemen. She pointed
out in this case Jupiter Inlet Colony is serviced by the Village's EMS program.
She commented because of that the Village's firefighters are entitled to receive
that portion of the state insurance money. She stated if Jupiter Inlet Colony would
work with the Village, and adopt a resolution in support of that, then the monies
that they are already paying, that are being kept by the State would come back to
the Village's EMS department, and result in a pension benefit for our guys. She
mentioned to some degree, because of the problems between them and the
Village, relating to mail service, and maybe a few other things, they have done
nothing to date. She indicated they received a copy of the resolution and a letter,
and have been approached, and nothing has happened. She explained she was
hoping the Village Council would write a letter explaining how this is not costing
them anything. She pointed out they have already paid the monies, and it is
simply putting the money back into a local pocket.
15
Minutes -Village Council Regulaz Meeting 03/09/06
Page 16
Council Member Genco mentioned Pension Board Attorney Jensen had written
Jupiter Inlet Colony a very nice explanation of it. She asked if Council could send
a letter to each of their Council Members, asking them to please endorse this at a
Council Meeting. She felt that way they would have more opportunity to move
forwazd.
Mayor Humpage commented Council Member Genco had brought the
information to Council about two months ago, and nothing has been done.
Council Member Genco stated it has been longer than two months, probably five
months ago. Mayor Humpage explained the Board Attorney sent the resolution to
the Clerk at Jupiter Inlet Colony. Council Member Genco pointed. out the Mayor
and Clerk knows about the issue. She explained if Council could send a letter to
each Council Member it would give them an opportunity to discuss as a group,
and decide whether or not they want to put it on their agenda and vote to pass the
resolution. She indicated the Village sent them a sample resolution so they do not
need to spend any money drafting the document, and the Boazd has an attorney's
opinion explaining exactly what she has described to Council. She noted it would
not cost them anything, and maybe if Council sent them a letter the Village may
be able to push this thing forward. Mayor Humpage agreed that was a great idea.
Council Member Paterno questioned whether it would be in the best interest of
the Village to have someone go to their meeting to represent the Village if
needed. Council Member Genco stated the Village has offered and it has not gone
anywhere. Mayor Humpage commented firstly, they need to accept the fact that
the Village is interested, and maybe they would invite Council or Staff over there.
Council Member Genco noted the Board has actually offered, contacted them and
sent the information. She mentioned it has not been a top priority for them,
because of the election, or other matters. She indicated if this is not done by a
certain time, the city could lose the money for that yeaz. She stated the Public
Safety Boazd would like to start capturing that money, so the sooner the better off
the employees would be. Consensus of Council agreed to send a letter to each
Council Member at Jupiter Inlet Colony. Village Manager Couzzo indicated he
would take care of the matter.
MAYOR HUMPAGE
Village Employees - He mentioned he was very pleased with Staff that has
worked so hard with the Tequesta Drive Bridge issue. He indicated they did a
great job, and went beyond the call and everyone pitched in.
Publix Site Plan Update - He asked Village Manager Couzzo to give an update on
the new Publix. Village Manager Couzzo mentioned Staff has been working with
Publix for the last two weeks to finalize some issues. He explained Ms. Catherine
Hazding, Director of Community has been using some creative techniques to
finalize the site. He stated it appears they will be opening on April 6, 2006. He
explained at the end of the project they have a punch list of items to finish up.
16
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 17
Village Manager Couzzo commented Publix before they get ready to stock the
store and commit to it, four weeks before the project they want to make sure
everything is done. He stated Staff has made an arrangement with them to ensure
everything was done. He mentioned they worked it out with the Attorney to issue
them a Certificate of Occupancy (CO) with a contingency to present a Cashiers
check to bond the rest of the work in the amount of $75,000. Council Member
Genco asked the status of the landscaping in the plaza. She mentioned they were
supposed to be upgrading the landscaping and the center walkway with trees.
Village Manager Couzzo indicated Ms. Harding is working with them on a daily
basis. He explained Ms. Harding went so far to hire an independent landscape
architect to ensure the quantity and the quality, and the character of the materials
is what the Village wanted.
Ms. Catherine Harding, Director of Community Development mentioned they had
an original plan that was approved by the Planning and Zoning Advisory Board,
and they did not comply with that fully, so she hired an outside consultant to
review the work they had done from the original plan, and they were very
cooperative and coming into compliance. She indicated Publix would give
everything on the plan and more that was required of them. Council Member
Genco explained she knew there was more landscaping on the approved plan,
other then what they put in. Ms. Harding commented the Village was looking for
60% of native plants, and they are complying with that. She mentioned she had
issues with them, but they were very good about it. She indicated the owner of the
shopping center is totally cooperating with Staff, so she felt everything would be
great when it was completed. Village Manager Couzzo mentioned Staff had the
good fortune of going inside the facility the other day, and it is a rather unique
looking store inside. He pointed out it is not the typical Publix layout, the bottom
half looks like the other stores, but the top half looks like a European Village
setting. He noted it was huge, and would have everything, everyone would want.
IX. NEW BUSINESS
7. Council discussion and possible action regarding the Tequesta Drive
Bridge traffic and weight limits.
Mayor Humpage gave a brief synopsis of the Village accomplishments
regarding the Tequesta Drive Bridge repairs. He mentioned many people
called and were so pleased the bridge repairs were done quickly, so the
bridge could reopen. He commented one of the primary concerns Council
has heard from the citizens was reopening the bridge to particular types of
traffic, such as the school buses, to get the children to school earlier to
prevent all the additional time. He commented that was the primary focus
of the discussion this evening, noting everything was set to go, and the
Village received another notice from the State earlier today; he
commented they are using extreme due diligence and having everyone
check out the bridge.
17
Minutes -Village Council Regulaz Meeting 03/09/06
Page 18
Village Manager Couzzo mentioned the Village completed its work on the
bridge last week, and what has happened is the Village has an engineering
recommendation from Bridge Design Engineering Associates that put
together the plans for the repair of the Bridge. He noted in that
recommendation, he is recommending the bridge weight limit not exceed
25 tons. He mentioned the State, who also does bridge inspections, has
contracted with a Tampa firm to do inspections, and they came out
yesterday to look at the bridge and start their analysis. He recommended to
Assistant Manager Gazlo that the Village get a preliminary report from
them as to what they think should happen with the bridge. He mentioned
Mr. Gazlo spoke with them, and the Village has received a letter regazding
the discussion.
Assistant Village Manager Robert Garlo mentioned he spoke with the
engineer from Kisinger Campo and Associates (KSA) yesterday when he
was doing the post-repair inspection that is required by Department of
Transportation (DOT). He commented Council received the draft report
the engineer was sending to DOT. He summarized the process: the
engineers data will be given to DOT, and DOT will take the data and do
an analysis on it, and do a load rating based on the information. He stated
DOT's requirement is to do the report within 45 days. He indicated the
Village has been getting a lot of cooperation from the DOT, and could get
the report much sooner. He mentioned in the absence of the completion of
the load analysis, KSA's recommendation was to keep it, in the current
condition, at 5 tons and 15 miles an hour until the numbers are projected.
He stressed also the engineer indicated to him that he would expect, based
on the data, that the allowable load limit would be close to the engineers
recommendation from Bridge Design Engineering Associates.
Council Member Genco asked if their recommendation after the repairs
was going to be to close to the 25 ton. Mr. Gazlo responded in the
affirmative. Village Manager Couzzo indicated he spoke with the bridge
design engineer and advised him of KSA's report, and he was not
surprised at their recommendation. Council Member Genco clarified that
the DOT recommended the weight limit of 5 tons, and the speed limit of
15 mph should be left in place. Village Manager Couzzo stated that was
correct, noting that he spoke with the Village Attorney, and the Village
Attorney contacted the Council individually after receiving the
engineering report late this afternoon. Attorney Hawkins pointed out since
Council is dealing with a public safety, health concern issue; he felt the
Village needed to err on the side of caution. He recommended Council
abide by the direction given in the report, to maintain the current
limitations, until they have further evidence in their files.
L'
18
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 19
Council Member Genco explained getting the letter was frightening to her,
because the Village's engineering report may be valid, it possibly may not
be with a real weight load bearing test, and 25 tons may not be the weight
factor that the bridge can take. She stated in the mean time the Village has
people violating the 5-ton. She asked if Staff could put out a flashing sign,
or something. Village Manager Couzzo noted Staff was looking into that,
and the police department has been aggressively enforcing it. He
mentioned Police Chief Allison is out there personally doing it himself. He
noted the Chief pulled over a bus and truck yesterday. Council Member
Genco commented they are doing a great job, but she missed the signs,
and she lives here, and others may not see the sign. She suggested
something blinking would help. Consensus of Council agreed to a blinking
sign.
Village Manager Couzzo explained the Village was not anticipating
getting this letter from the engineers, and it kind of was a surprise. He
stated he was confident that the Village's engineering numbers are on the
conservative side. He explained the State (DOT) is going to come in a
look, and will not commit until they have done their final analysis.
Council Member Genco commented in preparation of having a higher
weight limit then the 5 tons, would there be anyway to find out if the
school buses could go to a smaller vehicle if the bridge goes to a 15 ton
weight limit. Village Manager Couzzo indicated Staff would check with
the School Boazd and advise them of the bridge limitations and make
recommendations. Council Member Genco indicated then they could stazt
looking at whether or not they have buses, and do some rerouting, and if
Council makes some changes they will be prepazed to implement right
away. Assistant Village Manager Gazlo indicated Staff would talk to the
School Boazd's transportation department. He pointed out he expects to
have the final report from DOT with a load rating maybe within a week or
two. Village Manager Couzzo agreed, and felt the Village should
encourage them and assist them in expediting the analysis. He noted at
Council direction if they wanted to have a Special Meeting to address the
report.
Vice Mayor Watkins commented the primary thing since the bridge re-
opened was the calls that Council has received were in reference to the
school buses. She mentioned she understands it is a terrible inconvenience,
and it is time, and they have to go around and are on a schedule. She
explained she was also surprised to get this letter late this afternoon
talking about leaving it at the 5-ton limit. She stated in her opinion, she
does not see the Village having a choice, and if that is what DOT is
recommending, that is what Council has to do. She suggested Council
should be looking ahead, since they know the bridge will need to be
addressed again, that the Village should be thinking towazd possibly
19
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 20
budgeting a design for the new bridge, and looking forward to the next
step down the road.
Council Member Genco explained former Mayor Dorothy Campbell said
the Tequesta Drive Bridge was deeded over to the Village by the DOT at
some point in the 1970's. She stated if the Village is going to build
another bridge is it possible to look to DOT for helping us, because she
would not want the Village to own it. She stated the Village needed to
look at that, because the Village is responsible for all the maintenance.
Village Manager Couzzo agreed the Village could look into it, but felt the
DOT's position would be the same as the Village's; they would not want
to own it. Council Member Genco commented they own all the rest of the
bridges. Village Manager Couzzo pointed out the County owns a lot of
them. He stated the State has to take monies out of their tax base to
maintain the bridges, so the ones they can get off their list, they aze going
to try and do that. Council Member Genco agreed with Vice Mayor
Watkins, that Council would probably need to discuss at a workshop in the
future. She stated because a lot of the population that uses the bridge does
not live in Tequesta; she felt the Village needed to look at some kind of
joint consortium to do this and maintain the bridge. Attorney Hawkins
stated he felt it was a regional resource.
Council Member Paterno felt it was a good idea to put up a flashing sign
on the tonnage limit. He stated our own engineer said 25 tons, and the
estimate is 5 to 7 yeazs for usage of the bridge. Village Manager Couzzo
felt that estimate was based on the other spans that would then need to be
replaced. He stated there is another product that is revolutionary to extend
the life of bridges. He mentioned there may be other options. Council
Member Paterno noted at the same time in his engineering report, the one
the Village hired, said going forwazd every year the Village may have to
reduce the tonnage, because the bridge is going to get more wear and teaz
on it. He stated he would like to keep the tonnage low in order to have
some longevity to the bridge. He stated it would be very costly, and at the
same time residents on both sides of the bridge like the lower tonnage,
because it has cut down considerably on the through traffic, and they felt
their quality of life with the children was safer.
Council Member Paterno stated in reference to enforcement of the bridge
limits in the future there is a possibility of having cameras to record
license plates of people going over to record tonnage. He suggested the
Village could send the violators a letter and/or a ticket. He felt the Village
should explore it, and some of the technology that is available now, as a
community to make it safer for the bridge and our community. He felt this
would be a great opportunity for the Village. Village Manager Couzzo
commented in regazd to the cameras he was going to submit a proposal to
Council to do that.
20
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 21
Village Manager Couzzo mentioned Council Member Paterno was correct;
the Village could issue tickets if the ordinances are set up correctly. He
commented the technology is there, and the Village could look at child
predators and felons that have outstanding warrants, and match up license
plates. He commented the Police Department would do it automatically.
Council Member Genco commented she understood in the case of
commercial vehicles, because they have not actually seen the person
driving the truck the Village could not issue a ticket. She stated if they do
not have a commercial license to be in the Village, the Police Department
could issue some type of fine, or a warning if they see the truck again
without the license, or violating the tonnage. Village Manager Couzzo
noted Staff will take a look at the legislation, and maybe there is a chance
to modify it to some degree. He indicated Council Member Genco was
correct the Village could do that.
Mayor Humpage asked the Chief how the cameras work. He asked if the
camera photographs the vehicle and has the tag number could the Police
Department cite the vehicle, do they have to know who the driver is.
Police Chief Steve Allison stated they have had cases where the owner has
been called to the scene, and they fired them on the spot for violating
tonnage or speed limits. He commented the Police Department has had a
lot of cooperation from the commercial businesses. He felt sending a letter
that they were in violation would really help keep the route clear. Mayor
Humpage clarified if he drove a truck over the bridge that is 10 tons, and
the camera photographs the back side of the truck with the tag, can the
Village of Tequesta write a ticket to that vehicle, or does the Police
Department have to know the operator of the vehicle, and view the
operator. Chief Allison stated unless the law has changed very recently,
the Police Department would have to know who the operator is.
Council Member Paterno asked how does the Turnpike do it when they
send the $100.00 fine, and/or a parking ticket when they do not know who
is in the car. He felt they gave it to the car, not necessarily the driver that
parked it there. Chief Allison commented he would check into it, but noted
the Village's transponders have failed and the police department gets the
warnings back from the State. Mayor Humpage stated for example if
someone goes through the Sun Pass lane and you do not have Sun Pass,
they do not get the picture of the person driving, they get the vehicle.
Council Member Genco indicated they send a warning. Council Member
Paterno stated the first time they send a warning. Mayor Humpage asked if
Staff could look into that. Chief Allison commented he would check it out.
Council Member Genco stated if it is a commercial truck and it is not
licensed to do business in the Village, the Police Department could get
them from that side. Mayor Humpage agreed, and stated they may not
have a permit, either.
21
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 22
Council Member Genco felt that was the whole point, if that is the case,
the Village should send them a letter fining them for violating our
commercial code requiring them to pay the license fee, and a warning that
if it happens again the police department will do whatever they need to do.
Village Manager Couzzo indicated he will give Council the information
tomorrow regarding the cameras, and the police department is going to
aggressively enforce the weight limits. He felt it was a good suggestion,
and Staff will try and have the flashing lights by the end of the day
tomorrow.
Mayor Humpage mentioned this Council meeting was to help the citizens,
and the children using the school buses. He commented what he finds
absolutely amazing after he got the letter; since he has kept every sheet of
paper on this bridge since they started, all the State reports and looked at
the dates; that the Village of Tequesta can attack a problem like this
bridge, take the old one apart, and replace it in 7 days. He noted the
concrete chippers from the State need 45 days to figure out if the bridge is
any good. He stated he is absolutely astounded by that fact; he felt
someone needed to build a fire under these State guys. He stated they need
to get some resolution here, this Council is trying to do the right thing, and
the Staff works hard, and while they were out in the barge looking around,
it could take less then 45 days, but within 45 days, and Village replaced
the entire bridge in 7 days. He stated this Council would make every
effort, and this Staff, to pressure the State providing this information as
soon as possible. He suggested if they would like to call their State
representatives and tell them, the public would like to have the
information on this bridge, as soon as possible, so that the Village could
do something for the school children.
Village Manager Couzzo mentioned State Representative Joe Negron has
already been working on the Village's behalf to try and get some funding
to help offset the Village's costs to repair the bridge. He stated Staff will
put a call into his office tomorrow, and he probably will be pleased to call
the Secretary of the Department of Transportation. Mayor Humpage stated
he agreed with Council, that they have to take public safety first; and
foremost. He noted as the Attorney said, if Council was not to go along
with the State recommendation, and use the Village's engineer opinion,
and someone was injured the Village could be wide open for a lawsuit. He
felt the Council does not have a lot of options.
(Public Comments)
Mr. Joe Baker, resident of Fairview East commented he has been told he is
not allowed to take a car with a trailer behind it over the bridge. He asked
if that was still in place. Mayor Humpage stated 5- ton weight limit is in
place. Mr. Baker asked if that is total weight. Mayor Humpage agreed.
22
Minutes -Village Council Regulaz Meeting 03/09/06
Page 23
Mr. Baker pointed out, the weight signs on the bridge aze inconsistent; the
one on the west side says "5 ton", the one on the east side says "5 ton net".
He explained the difference is "net" is empty, and suggested the word
"net" needed to be removed from the sign. Consensus of Council agreed.
Mr. Basil Dalack, resident of Golfview Drive, and incoming Council
Member asked if the 15 mph speed limit was still in effect. Mayor
Humpage stated yes. Vice Mayor Watkins pointed out 5 tons, 15 miles per
hour.
Council Member Paterno pointed out the one thing that was addressed
about the trailers, he felt Council only allowed passenger vehicles 5 tons,
no trailers. He stated that was so the Police would have a little easier time
at policing it, so if someone goes over with a truck and he is pulling a
trailer, the police does not have to question whether it is over or not. He
explained he thought Council had discussed no trailers at one time.
Council Member Genco commented she came over with an empty sea-doo
trailer, and they would not let her over the bridge. She felt that the Village
has to be reasonable about it, and felt the restriction was for commercial
trailers. She commented someone with a boat or sea-doo is not a problem.
Mayor Humpage stated the person with a backhoe, or bobcat on the back
of the lawn truck is a problem. Council Member Genco stated the officer
did the right thing, because that is what Council's rule was, so she does
not have any fault with it. She pointed out there needs to be some
reasonableness to it. Council Member Paterno commented he understands,
but for Chief Allison he needs some direction as to what it means.
Council Member Genco stated it has to be reasonable, but if you have a
passenger caz, with an empty trailer that should be allowed. Council
Member Paterno stated no commercial trucks. Council Member Genco
agreed no commercial, but felt Council needed to allow the Police
Department to have discretion on that. Mayor Humpage commented he
felt the Police Department was doing a great job. Council Member Genco
agreed they are doing a phenomenal job. Mayor Humpage stated this
afternoon he saw a lawn maintenance truck pulling a trailer with a bobcat
on it, so he thought about turning azound following it to see if it would
have violated the rule. He mentioned the police department cannot be
everywhere, and he felt they were doing a great job. Council Member
Genco commented that is through traffic; and through traffic is not
suppose to be allowed. Mayor Humpage pointed out in the morning is
when predominately that type of traffic is crossing the bridge, when
people aze going to work and then coming home in the afternoon. He
suggested maybe the police department could enforce those restrictions
during the am and pm peak hours.
•
23
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 24
Vice Mayor Watkins commented she did not remember the discussion
regarding personal vehicles pulling trailers, so is it allowed or not. Mayor
Humpage stated it is, but the police department will use their discretion.
Council Member Genco pointed out Council had said no trailers. She
pointed out apparently they were concerned with the closed trailers
coming through, attached to vehicles, which who knows what could have
been there. She stated she did not have a problem with giving the police
officers some discretion to use common sense on some of those things.
She mentioned when Council gave the police department the blanket order
they enforced it completely, and totally proper. She felt knowing the
Village is going into alonger-term situation; maybe Council needs to give
them a little discretion.
Vice Mayor Watkins asked Chief Allison if that direction was clear to
him. She commented she wanted to understand what the Chief understood
this to mean. Mr. Baker asked how they would establish the weight of a
vehicle going over the bridge. He asked what happens when the Village
has a 25-ton limit, are they going to go back and say tractor-trailer, and the
Village not knowing what is inside the vehicle. Council Member Genco
noted the problem is they do not have anything to weight it. Mr. Baker
pointed out the police has scales they weight the vehicles. Mayor
Humpage stated that could cost the Village a small fortune to implement
that.
Chief Allison agreed the police department would exercise their
discretion. He noted they would concentrate on the commercial vehicles,
the big landscape trailers. He stated he will have someone out there at the
peak am and pm hours. He felt it does make sense to let some of the
smaller lightweight trailers cross the bridge. Council Member Genco noted
Council did not allow any discretion before and did not see a problem with
giving it to the police department.
Council Member Paterno commented from the standpoint of through
traffic when they are not going over the bridge, they are going by Council
Member Genco's on Country Club Drive. He commented he is trying to
address a through problem, because when the police are out there working,
it could be a small thing, but it is a commercial vehicle going through, and
there is a 5000 pound limit, so from a practically point, sometimes he has
to just let them go, and the Village ends up back where they were a month
ago with through traffic. He stated he is just trying to bring that out, and
does not want the through traffic. Council Member Genco commented if
someone has a couple of gallons of pool cleaner, they are servicing the
Village, and the residents in the Country Club, Tequesta Point, or
Bermuda Terrace, or whatever, those are not the people Council is
concerned with. She felt if Council said no trailers, police have to enforce
it that way.
24
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 25
Council Member Genco stated Council has not given them discretion; and
suggested giving them the discretion to use their common sense when they
are implementing this for the Village. Consensus of Council agreed to give
the police department discretion to use their common sense when they are
enforcing the restrictions.
8. RESOLUTION 60-05/06 - A Resolution of the Village Council of the
Village of Tequesta, Palm Beach County, Florida, approving the purchase
of a 4000-gallon Fuel Tank from Glasgow Equipment Service, Inc., in the
amount of $55,186.00. This purchase by the Public Works Department is
part of the Village's Hurricane Preparedness Program. Cost to be funded
by the existing Hurricane Wilma Reserve Contingency account #001-990-
599.902.
Attorney Hawkins read for the record the title of Resolution 60-05/06.
Assistant Village Manager Robert Garlo mentioned the Village once again
is in hurricane preparation. He stated one of the things the Village saw last
year was a critical fuel shortage after Hurricane Wilma. He indicated after
reading the Village's Emergency Management Plan it is the responsibility
of Public Works to ensure the availability of fuel during an emergency. He
suggested Council consider the purchase of this fuel tank to be housed at
the Public Works Facility. He noted this would provide for both gas and
diesel fuel for the Village during and after an event like last year.
Council Member Genco asked if that was the reason the tank was split.
Mr. Garlo stated yes, and mentioned he spoke with Mr. Russell White,
Public Services Manager and he has machinery over at the Water Plant
that requires diesel fuel that is necessary during restoration after a storm.
He indicated the Village also ran into a problem getting Regular gasoline
after the storm, so this would allow them to fuel up police cars. Mayor
Humpage noted last year they used a plastic container on wheels, which is
considerably more dangerous. He mentioned this would keep the Police
and Fire trucks in fuel in the event we need them. He commented this is
why the Village has this money in place to make our preparations. Vice
Mayor Watkins noted we are very fortunate the Village is small enough
that Council is able to do this sort of thing, and provide for the citizens.
She noted she was for anything that would help the Village is this manner.
Council Member Paterno asked if the Village was going to use this all
year round, or just store for emergency purposes. Mr. Garlo stated the
Public Works and Utility Departments would probably realize a cost
savings in bulk fuel, if they use for the equipment continuously. He
indicated whether they extend it to the entire fleet, he has not yet discussed
that with the Village Manager, but they could look at that.
25
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 26
Mayor Humpage commented with the shelf life they would want to keep
the fuel moving, and with the bulk purchase the Village is going to save
money and dollars per gallon over the long haul. Mr. Garlo indicated
public works and utilities would be using the fuel. Village Manager
Couzzo noted they are going to try and provide it to the entire fleet. He
indicated the Village would be buying it directly from the Port at a much
better price.
Council Member Paterno commented in reference to the $408,000, it says
the actual cost to repair and restoration is expected to be less than
appropriated. He asked how much money would be left over, not spent,
after this item. Mr. Garlo stated he did not have that exact number, only
because all the repairs have not been completed. He noted he is confident
with purchase they still will be able to do complete restoration and repairs
and not exceed that $408,000.00. He mentioned a significant savings came
from debris removal. Mayor Humpage commented it came in at
$90,000.00 instead of $130,000.00. Mr. Garlo stated the original estimate
was $155,000.00.
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to approve Resolution 60-05/06; seconded by
Council Member Paterno; motion passed 4-0.
9. RESOLUTION 61-05/06 - A Resolution of the Village Council of the
Village of Tequesta, Palm Beach County, Florida, Awarding a Contract to
Chaz Equipment Co, Inc. of Wellington, Florida, in the amount of
$110,000.00 for the Rolling Hills Water Main Extension installation,
having been budgeted FY 2005/2006 in Water Utility Fund #401 account
#401-414-662.637 in the amount of $110,000.00 and the RO Well 4
Pipeline installation in the amount of $298,000.00 having been budgeted
FY 2005/2006 account #401-414-662.641 in the amount of $327,500.00
and authorizing the Village Manager to execute the applicable contracts on
behalf of the Village.
Attorney Hawkins read for the record the title of Resolution 61-05/06.
Mayor Humpage passed the gavel to Vice Mayor Watkins, and stepped out of the
room 9:00 P.M.
MOTION: Council Member Genco moved to approve Resolution 61-05/06; seconded
by Council Member Paterno. (Vote to follow at end of discussion)
Mr. Russell White, Public Services Manager mentioned this is two
pipelines: 1) Rolling Hills loop, which the Village is doing to help the
system hydraulically increase pressure and flow to some of the northern
areas of the system; and 2) RO Main is for the new well the Village is
drilling over by the Public Service Building.
26
Minutes -Village Council Regulaz Meeting 03/09/06
Page 27
Mr. White stated the Main needed to be installed before the well was
completed, so they can develop the well. He mentioned the contractor that
bid on the Rolling Hills loop gave the Village a good number on the water
Main; then gave a good number for the Change Order (CO) to do the RO
Main. He commented if this item is approved, they would do the RO Main
immediately, that way the Village would be sure to meet the timeframes
for the Well.
Vice Mayor Watkins commented she knew it was a tight timeframe.
Council Member Genco pointed out the $110,000.00 was something
Council already addressed at a prior Council Meeting, because it had to do
with Rolling Hills, and they approved the water extension. She noted the
$298,245.00 was not something that Council addressed in the budget,
because it did not really exist at that time of the budget. Mr. White
commented that is correct. Council Member Genco explained if she added
those two numbers together that comes to $408,245.00. She stated she has
some questions about the math, mostly about the $298,245.00 would be
coming out of a Capital Outlay Fund, which did not have this item
budgeted. Mr. White explained they did pull money out of Reserves and
appropriated it to that Fund.
Village Manager Couzzo felt the money was approved, because Staff
came to Council to discuss expanding the system and the grant money the
Village was going to receive. Council Member Genco commented the
$700,000 dollars, and then Mr. Bill Reese talked about he was not certain.
She stated she remembered they had some subsequent conversations about
whether or not the Village would have to do the water extension. Village
Manager Couzzo clarified the grant was approved for the extension of the
piping, and the new well. He indicated the Village accepted the grant and
appropriated the funds from the Capital account, because the money was
in there. He noted this item was now addressing the contract, and it was a
creative way of doing it; hitching on to the previous contract, so both of
those contracts go together. He stated when they did this initially they
knew they were under incredible time constraints as faz as getting this
done, and being in accordance with the time of the grant. He stressed they
thought it would be advantageous to the Village, initially, and long term to
have this additional resource. He commented Staff has negotiated, as the
Council approved, with the well driller, and it came in less then what
Council had authorized. He commented that well drilling contract has
been executed and the well driller will be onsite next Friday. He stated it
was kind of like the bridge; stated he does not know why the Village
always seems to find ourselves in these timeframes, but this has got to be
done real fast. He pointed out the money was there.
Council Member Genco agreed, to get the grant money the Village was
proceeding with this; she understood and was not in disagreement with it.
27
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 28
Council Member Genco stated if Council was taking money out of the
Capital Outlay Fund, which it appears they are taking out $327,000.00.
Mr. White stated $327,000.00 was for the pipeline. Council Member
Genco felt the math was not working, because she was adding
$110,000.00 to 298,245.00, and came up with $408,245.00. Mr. White
agreed, and noted $110,000.00 was in the Capital Expansion Projects
Fund. He stated the $110,000.00 and the $298,000.00 comes to the
$408,000.00, but if you take the $327,000.00 and $110,000.00 there would
still be plenty of money in the budget. Council Member Genco
commented the $327,500.00 really was not budgeted. Mr. White pointed
out they re-appropriated the funds and amended the budget for the
$327,000.00. Council Member Genco questioned why taking $408,245.00.
Mr. White commented the funding was coming from two separate
accounts: the amended budget that was appropriated, or money that had
already been approved in the original budget. He mentioned the RO well
money was appropriated and the budget was amended, Rolling Hills was
budgeted for in the original budget. Council Member Genco stated she
agreed these two items were $408,245.00. Mr. White responded that is
correct, and noted out of the $408,000.00, $110,000.00 is out of the
Capital Expansion Projects Fund, that has a budget of $110,000.00.
Council Member Genco pointed out that is line item 637, and line item
641, is $327,500.00. Mr. White stated that is where the $298,000.00 would
come from.
Council Member Genco asked what would happen with the rest of the
money. Mr. White mentioned it says there, and if they do not use it and
everything goes smoothly, they will not spend all of the $408,000.00; it
goes back into the Reserve. Council Member Genco stated that is what
Staff needs to do; they need to transfer that money back into the Reserve.
Mr. White pointed out when money is budgeted for something like this, as
soon as the project is completed that money will go back, but if something
happens during this pipeline where they need a change order for $5,000.00
or $10,000.00 Staff still has the money in there so they do not need to
come back to Council and re-appropriate more money. Council Member
Genco commented the total remaining difference is $81,245.00, and that is
a lot of money.
Mayor Humpage indicated that money would go back to Reserves. Mr.
White stated when they budget they need to be cautious, because it is hard
to budget for the future. Council Member Genco indicated she was ok
with that, but as Council Member Paterno has pointed out to Council
before that once there is a line item that has a budget savings, that should
automatically be transferred back into the Reserve fund. Mr. White stated
that is the case, as soon as the project has been completed, the purchase
order is closed out and the money goes back to Reserves.
28
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 29
Mr. White noted it would not sit there for the rest of the year for Staff to
use it. Council Member Genco explained it used to sit there and be clipped
away. Mr. White stated when the purchase order was closed the money is
gone, so it is no longer there to spend. Council Member Genco
commented this is large item, because Council did not budget for it
originally, and she wanted to make sure the money goes back.
Vice Mayor Watkins asked if the Village is on the timeframe regarding the
grant. Village Manager Couzzo commented the timeframe with the grant
is very aggressive, and they are pushing as hard as they can. He mentioned
they have not cut ground yet, so they do not know what problems they are
going to incur there. He indicated Staff is guardedly optimistic that they
are going to meet the deadline. He mentioned hopefully the Village does
not encounter a hurricane.
Mayor Humpage returned to the room at 9:05 P.M.
Council Member Paterno mentioned he is conscious of that extra money,
and as long as everyone understands it is to be automatically transferred
back when the Purchase Order closes. He stated he would like that
reflected in the minutes. Village Manager Couzzo stated it goes back, like
the Tropic Vista project that was closed yesterday. Council Member
Genco stated Staff did a great job. Council Member Paterno felt this was a
great project, and he has confidence that Mr. White will get it done,
because he has got it this far.
Vice Mayor Watkins returned the gavel to the Mayor, and stated they previously
had a motion, and second. Motion passed 4-0.
X. ANY OTHER MATTERS
Vice Mayor Watkins commented Council was going to set the next
workshop date. Village Manager Couzzo suggested the Village Clerk
contact Council to coordinate a workshop date. Mayor Humpage
commented Council had set the workshop priorities and suggested the
Clerk give Council some dates. He noted the primary issues at this time
were the Boat Issue, then the golf cart issue. He commented these two
issues should be addressed after incoming Council Member Dalack is
seated. Consensus of Council agreed to have the Clerk arrange dates and
coordinate schedules with Council and Mr. Dalack.
Council Member Paterno commented he had a few people tell him they
were happy about the "No fishing on the Bridge:, especially the lady
whose son was caught with a hook going under the bridge. He mentioned
the family feels more comfortable now going under the bridge.
[~
29
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 30
Council Member Paterno indicated others told him for safety sake, they
thought is was prudent to restrict the fishing from the bridge. Mayor
Humpage commented there was an incident in Delray Beach where a boy
caught a fish off the bridge, and he was reeling it in and the line broke.
The boy feel back and the truck ran over him because there was no back
guardrail. Council Member Genco stated she appreciated Council
addressing that issue, because it was something they talked about many
times at Council Meetings.
Vice Mayor Watkins mentioned she and her fellow Council Members
were looking forward to having Council Member Dalack join them. She
stated it would be nice to have a full Council again.
A resident of Tequesta commented talking about people fishing from the
bridge, he has seen people fishing on the rocks. Mayor Humpage noted he
did not mind that as much, as long as they do not throw their lines in the
water. Mayor Humpage indicated he has not seen anyone fishing lately.
Council Member Genco asked if the police department had a hard time
enforcing the fishing restrictions. Police Chief Allison indicated there was
no problem.
Ms. Betty Nagy, resident of Shay Place asked if the notice for the Boat
workshop meeting was going be placed in the Smoke Signals. She
mentioned this workshop would not only be for the people in homeowners
associations, but for all Tequesta residents. She felt there were other
people in the Village that had the right to give their input. Mayor
Humpage agreed, but noted the timing of the Smoke Signals may not work
out with the meetings, because it is a quarterly newsletter. He stated they
will get the message out to everyone in the Village, and they could do a
dialogic message. Village Manager Couzzo stated Staff would do a small
ad in the Jupiter Courier also. Ms. Nagy agreed, noting it is such an
important issue and everyone has the right to voice their opinions.
Mr. Joe Baker, resident of Fairview East thanked Council for the dialogic
messages the residents have received. Council Member Genco commented
the Police Chief brought forward that item to Council.
Mr. Basil Dalack, resident of Golfview Drive and incoming Council
Member asked if there was a public service section in the newspaper that
will publish notices of meetings. Mayor Humpage stated the Village does
that. Mr. Dalack commented so the Village does not pay unnecessarily; he
asked Council to consider any request by a Council Member to have an
item placed on the agenda is a matter of discretion, he felt it has to be
placed. He stated if you read any resolution, there is a place for a second
to the motion; there is an offer, then a second, and if no one seconds the
motion the resolution dies.
30
Minutes -Village Council Regular Meeting 03/09/06
Page 31
Mr. Dalack stated if they do not like the item that is their privilege. In
addition, he felt any member of the Village has the right ask any member
of the Council to propose a resolution or ordinance, or whatever. He
commented if Council does not pay attention, he thinks they have that
right. He felt when it comes to putting something on the agenda it is not
discretionary whether it would be accepted or not. He commented it would
save the wear and tear on the law books, and on the Village's bank
account. Council Member Genco explained they had discussed that
originally when Council developed the policy, but the Council decided to
change it to what they are currently using. She stated at this point in time,
since Council is questioning that policy, either Council revises it as Mr.
Dalack suggested, or if Council chooses not to revise it that way, which
would have been following Roberts Rules and adhere to the policy
Council established then they have no choice but to be assured that the
Village is legally correct. Mayor Humpage commented he believed the
previous policy was any Council Member can request something be put on
the agenda, but then Council rescinded that and it had to be a consensus of
Council to place something on the agenda.
Mayor Humpage asked if Attorney Hawkins could take a look at this.
Village Manager Couzzo suggested another way would be to have Staff
look into it, and if there were any questions, he would call Attorney
Hawkins. He commented he would also review with Mr. Dalack. Mayor
Humpage stated he wanted Council and Mr. Dalack to be comfortable
with this, because everyone has to work together. Council Member
Paterno asked for clarification on the issue. Village Manager Couzzo
commented Staff would take a look at the issue, and confer with the
Attorney and see if it required any additional research on Mr. Hawkins
part. He felt in his opinion the issue may remedy itself very quickly. He
commented if there is a statute in place, they could read it and make an
interpretation, and confer with the Attorney if a recommendation is
needed. Council Member Paterno summarized if the Statute and the
Village's policy are conflicting Council would go with the Statute, but if
the Village's policy does not conflict, then Council is staying with their
policy. Consensus of Council agreed.
XI. ADJOURNMENT
MOTION: Vice Mayor Watkins moved to adjourn the Meeting; seconded by Council
Member Genco; motion passed 4-0.
The ~f re the Meeting wa/s.adjourned at 9:15 P.M.
Gwen Carlisle
Village Clerk
31