Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutDocumentation_Regular_Tab 09_06/11/2015 - : � FMAIL CLERiC � � i�int Form VILLAGE CLERK'8 OFFfCE � AGENDA ITEM ROUTING SHEET +� Meeting Datie IlAeetin9 TYpe� Regulet Ordi�nce #: May 14, 2015 �� Ag° NO �olutlon #: 19-i5 Orighsattng Deparbne� Buiiding RESOLUTION N0.19-15 . � . Account #: N/A Amou� of �ts ftem: N/A Bud�etsd �t►ount av�ilabl�: N/A Amount remaining afb� item: NiA Budgat ts�tnsfsr requlred: N►p ApPropMaibe Fund Balance: N/A - . Appendix C- Permit Fees. SeCtian (A} Bufidtng Pennit Feas - da�flcation of bui�ing permit 1�ees to be more user tr�tuily f� s�if a� pubNc use; new ver�age regarding p�mit eurpiration/ext�nsion� initiai ir�spec�lon and r+s-inspection and f�s mar�ated by Florida �; lists electric� �gn connedion t+aes roquired by oMM�uu�e pr+eviously not listed; creat� fixed rate for Derno,Tempa�ary CO/COC: creat�es new buslr�ss "Stnc�Cic� Pennit� fee and FEMA Trei�r i�ees; aeates minir�m Pian Revie�w fee�; ct�tes P�tia1, Couit�l►, and ai�er hours inspeciion rat�; Section (B) C�ab� fise schedule !nr development permits withln the Ville�ge flood�in; flood zone de�enr�inatl�s; elevation �; floodplain Inspec�oas; ma� revis�cc�s, ebc. �qu�ed !�t Villa� Ftood Dama� Pr�eventlon Oniinance 7&71 t; � � . Deparbnent Head � L,e�al {fnr iegai sufflt�tcy) Rinance Dfrsctor or Representathre t Reviewed for �inanclal Su�cy Q� No F�nanda4 in�pact � Village Mana�er: Submit for Council Discussion: Q, � l( ap�ove Itam: E�� � DenY ttem: � •- Form Amended: 10/30/14 REROLUIZON N0.1915 A RESOLUITON OF '�'H�.? VILLAGE COUNCIL OF THE VILLAC�E OF TEQUESTA, FLORIDA, ADUP7'.INC� A REViSF.D PERMfT FEE S�HEDULE AS PROVIDED BY 3EC. I41 S2 OF THE VILLAt}E C�DE OF ORDINANCES; PROYIDINC� THAT THIS SCHEDULE OF FEES AND CHAR(�ES SHALL BE AVAII.AHLE FOR 1NSPECTZON AT ALL TIIu�S AT THE VBd.AC�E HALL DURING REC�ULARBUSINESS H4URS; PROVIDiNGFORPUBLICATION 4F TgIIS SCHEDULB OF FEES AND C�iARC�ES IN APPENDIX C. �F 1�1E VILLA(}8'S CODE OF URUINANCES; PROYIDINCi AN EFFECTIVE DATE; AND FOR OTHER PURP03ES. WHEREAS, th�e V'il1a Cou� of the V� of Toqucsta, Floriida, de�aires to adopt a rc,wisod pecmit Eae scl�dule for aII buildia�g ad�ivities ia tt�e V'iiLa�, iml�ing th�e a�oci�ed with the Villag�e's Soodplain m� o�din� fo� � citi�s of the Villa�e of Tequesta a�d f� otker membecR of the pablic; aad WHEREAS, t�e V�lage Ca�mcil cl�tires to ino�e sll suc� f�aes and c�h�r�cs a�dop�ed in sov�oe with Sevtion 14i 52 of tbe Cc�de of Ordina�oae ia�a one �v�e �ee sch+odule; ated WHEREAS, �e Village Council � to make c�ein tt�e achedule of f�eea snd � is available for inspec�ic� soch d�t any a�nbar of d�e �blic may be awac�e of tbe oost of Is�d develop� activity wi�tin the V'illege. NOW, TT�REFORE, BE 1T RESOLVED BY THB VII.LAGE COUNCII. OF THE VILLAGE OF TEQUESTA, PALM BEACH CO[7NTY, FLORIDA, AS FOLLOWS: Section 1: Tf�e Village Coun�cil of the V�la�e of Teques�, Flodda, hereby a�opts the r�vvisecl Scl�edule of Fe� amd Char�s attauched � as Eacldbit A aad a�e patt h�reof e�s if fuliy set forth herein Secaon 2: This duty edap�od Sct�odate of Fees ancl C�b�cges aball be ava�abk at tt�e Village H�lt for inspxtion by the public during nacrost bu� Zatn's, and sl�ell fiu�r be p�bii�od in Appendix C af t�e V'illage's Code of Otdina�uea. � This Resolution sbati take e�ct innmediatelY upa� adoption- :apP�=ra�tx c � ��fzr,uT r��:Es Ir�.1 �3UILDIrlG 1'ERP�11T FEES: ';. f�E3��li;,eition fe;,: ,.,,.�75,00 �� he ���EiE�li�;ation fee is nonrefun�i��f�if, an�l ad�ied to ti��> ��u��inii te:;, � �a � „:;:. ._. ;��• , � ,�iinim�imS4.Q0_perFS553J?i c. t3t�ilc3in�� p��i�r��it applicants for ne4v c�r �eplace�i7ent coinr�iercial buifdings, iis�v o� replacet�ie+�t niulti.fai�ril;� imilrli���� ; and netiv or replacement d±a�lexes shall pay a nonrefundable �3,OD�.OU fee at the tini�: of filing f��r � :>��ii;li;i,s ;�;�� ntik. ,�;��N�#i�as� f�n�i�rit r�pplicants for no;�� nr repiac�ment c��nvention�l sii��1.:-f,����ily re;ir.lence shaN pay a non•rr�fuc�rtal�le ;�1.5i)n.iJE; ;��,, �;t. ki�e CimF; ��; filinc� for �� ia�iil�liny ��:�rmit. � t3uil�iin<� I�ein�ii ap��lir,anis for na;�� or r�placLrnent inoriiilar homes shall �Say a n�n�refundable $750.(l0 (e� ai thc �irn�. a� iifing for a building Eaerrnit. �..� „' i)t'V �( �; %f-� 1;��i., :�'�:�a ;i��'S�!'� fJii (IIt�I� i.'ii;�i�1 ��u� i�lltk1t17ifhi � � ti� '��'i-n� ���- : " _ _. _ . . _ - --...._ ;��ul:{i}�g ;�en��iEa��licants for a new or replacerner�t n�obilehome a�eexen�}�t froni payiny an a{>plica#ion #ee aEthe ii}r�•v ot fili��g. l�E;a� auproval ar�ci perinitting tt3e a���4icablei�onrefuntlabie 1,uilciiE�y ��rfs�it feeshall be deducte�i fraf7 anyt�ther st,�aa�int�whiclt may be due a�iri�owing �tr�deF t�e�other�tantis of tliis s.�bsecti�n. ?. �1�e�S`�°C �]e�llll{t f08$ She'l�� hP, CSVU E)PfCOf)t t�� f�18 `lFI�UBflptl t6�'sl: �_2s i1 fi7(2!� a � , �li;l� i-:i'< iii? �;,�t�� Fw��s3; ��+�,�.� � „ � it � �,�r i� , E:tf ?iI°:� : �� �>>> ii��C011tf8C�0Y�., � � � � � �,+:`i�"� � itt` Il:rfi ,.:� I. ,,�,� t.�� �, I�:u ��i I,,.i:ilt)i1�t� :,r,t1�i�:c e�r,(;i, �i.lU f�;7SQIlab�E Qtir+� " S�ltl�� �)B G0�151(�. ft;C� ft1P, '' _ _ greater cl:anoinin,�tir�n ni ci�hr.r; 11. li�� �iu�-�i izee! contract betiveen the contractor anrl the o�,vner oi sucn property or building; or 3.The valuation method as det��rmined hy the Internationai 8uilriiny Code (IBC) Section 109.3. ,��bcr�ntractors working uncier,; i�iaster permit shail be issued a nc> fee permit to complet�a thoir ��rork if the master perinit issue�l incli.ide�i ihc�ir proposal the nonrefur�dable applicatioii 'iz�e of �75.00 will be reqtiired, :�il'faCUll�([il.�kOi� ;,'ll!)�.�Il�et :t:� � ���i..���,r ll.s(I�Ih , t>�t ��� r,., tf-Uii!' .t.t�`ij�i�� ifl'-' Ir:1��t11;. ! .�.�i;i i �Jsiil J�I�flS_3i1d�dOCUfti=�N i1 ritr�� � a�ittr�:�i+�.t Ii1ll�lititr�tl dt)(JII�:? ft'6' �a{ �,r ,F)I! a`�11I li,� i,�u��j��:�.i, 4. f'�rmit fees based up��n vali.iation �7hali be �:oller:ted to construct, e�ilar�e, alter, reE�aii�, r>>r,>>�;�, �{,�rnolish, or change the oc�;u{>�iacy of a I��iilding v�� stnict��re, c,r t� erect, instali, eniarc�e, alter, r�pair, renrov^, c�;m�:�� ���� i��r�,l<�r_.e ,.�r�y ,�e���ii;<:ci in�p�ct-r�.� �.i�s't;�ni aaverin,ys, electricai, y;�s, rn�r,hanical, or���linnhir�� syst�m, :i� ��, � ,��:G. i��1:r. � '��:�„� . � ; ;;.��� �,itc : i.�o:� r3.. the instaUation vf �^rhich is re_yui�ted k�y tiie �'lori�l;� ;;uil�iiu�� t:n�.i;, ,�n�! I"iz�ri�i�; ;'ire �'r��vention �:r,de, or to causc ,ni�� sur,h �,��or?� to h�� d�,ne, shal� first make a��plicatioi� to tir.�, lnailrlin�� official ai�d obtain tiae r=,���E,� ; ia��ces>ary perinit�s, b'Uor;; rec��riring such a permit includes, t�ut is not be limited t�, the follo���ing exa��inles. __ __ _ Ne1�� 5titicti�res Sea�,vallsi[����� �� Il. �rv� � ,Air cc�ndiiioners - --_ _ _ _ Rcr7os�atiora _�n�i demr�liki�:�n �C�ocksif�oat li�isl�iavits �.I;��;zt ����un; •���:I � 1��.° st�rs ,. , /�i(�C�IiJ��tl'; , stitiu!sifl�.* i�_il(f�� �I�lil� :' �;p � 'f'I(€? !SIUIQG��011 Sf4�t6'i11S " 1.��;Ffi1'> � _ i ,Acc� _ :;G->>y :;trt�r,tur��; (,. ,��, , i.,ir:.�� j �i.-+u�i �:leatin� i4 (r�e Rem4v��° �tniri�j systern; ivjOVi)ltJ D�fl�(�IIItjS �;7i�J�7';, Il(."r'! �)f IT10(�1fIBC� � �iti5 4'CfLIIt)lii;:l'I[ �-�tE�, , Flll(� �)I�)IIl(J f'I�CL'IOi�( ii(lt{ i't'��;i(S OIl �(�l(�C ���F?�l�tll Oi t!YI:itIillJ ',il�(IS `GiUtf£'.( DI' t{C)`�YIISf)UUtS � Seal s�atii,:; c�fr �,:�,,;ing lot =Lan�lsca;�iny 1� li� �)�ren+:h �lrai��s, ��i�� _�. ���., � Re-stripir�e� oi par,jing lot _ I�rir�i��ion systems 1\;�tning; u+ canopies, �;,I P�1i5c�llane�us con �iru�:tiori ;1'I�nniiinq ii��tailations ,Com�nercial : li !� .: ��ents :�nd ho+�>d:; � State ��pproved uiodul,ir u��its ;_:�;��: II'luinf�ing repairs So��r waier heate�~; '� ;,����; ;, ,.�� � Founrla?i�i�s f��r ii�odular units ?Set�rt.rfi�rainage � � . . Eitcirical instaliati��iis �' . , ,. ;� ; Ori�:e ��:;yv, -�,�(i.,-., and sirlewalks �S�onu tirainaye lines Elaekf�+catre}�airs � � � �I �� ��elchan9es � : �en�es anci tivalls �i: �{{,�,l�� �- �>v� r ?t�' �Wat=�r i�eate�ti �� �'�,�' �; � iri#�,tit3} �'� Exterior li±�htin�� �� ��oles ' - __ , t�00flil(J �10t)Elll'.i ill1C� IICi'l f0O(�� ��BtCi Ill�illl� �: E)fq� ��l�?': Z7('IIQI<It�)1'-- �ill(� tl'i1I1SfBf 5�!JltChe$ ��UIiIG.�lfli; )7Olt,Ct10(1 � i �i ( )pO�S %� � , � (�li):7(f)I111�;�5 �� '-'��;lil� ., 'i(�Ji__� i3�y� � � � . i�� .� , ��y'lili)II1111J I � � Flo��i1 ��r�»iiiic� panels �' �;��, �. ��.�,;� � ,, ,:s,r,� an�:l hot tui��; �Lo�,�r vr�l#a�e z i; ,,�i.�' �: ;'� alarm system ' �:�taiiiing e�r �i�� rap ti�r;�lis 'Seree» c:�x;icr.;u�c:;r� , �:levs�te,rs :' i :. , , '�Vintlos�tti;,, �, ienio��al and repl�cerner7t �tiV,�C�� f���stu�� �.� �� D�_in�b�;�aitei� r,li,�iirlifts __....� V'i�terE��ooiir�� oi areas �7ank� {��il type_,) Ilfiliiy wc�rk �� � � i•: ;ini�#•,of-way - - : 5. f'l; t'� ��I! ;'J�; „: Non•refur�dai�le plan reviaw fee and siaop dra�r�irig fee ro tw ��d�led ;��ith the kotal perr�iik fee; .S,,Oi)i25 times the valuation. * i`i �iUilt111� P�8t1 �B VI(;�J w flUfldE;fUl�t)'�i�;�j lilliiltilllfn I( ,: �)�lit• :ti'itl.[111 �,-tf ]�titlf +>i � sst '�'`!:f • _;�f�.���.�xtra "Job Co " - 25.0� (nan-refun�iablel A 50.Ofl minimum application !ee shall be due uuon submittal Each subseauent plan review after the third plan review rejected for a previously noted wolation shail be char�ed at four times the normai fee aer FS 553.80 {2�(b1, Plans drawn by a ficensed subcontractor when not rec�u,ired to be drawn bv a licensed architect or enpineer, shali include the contractor name, c ompanv na me business address and license number per FS 553.70 6, FIX ED fEt' ; Valuatian system shall not be usec.i if a Fixed fee is set below. � G�,r i"t�� ����� , ai i)rc�an�y t,ertiticate ut Cc,rri���i��r,i��n ( included in perm'rt • Te«i�r�+y i.0 f2 esidenti al_ - ��50.00 • TemQorary CO or COC Commerci�l & rni�lti-famil - 150_00 "�;��= l�i;��; i°� ;�,��ait �.�200.00 nn i i � �'��,i��ir� or fr�inin�� ,r�li��iti� _3if�r,�iad v�ithnu! T�i��ip��rniv C��) 3 �i eriipara�y electrica� service v+ �;: �; , :;I�; :.....$125AU a �(ern��orary constiiiction trailer; ,.,..��Utl.UO ; 7emn�rary sales traiier removal r:,���!ir�?�.I ;,�fiore certificat:; of occuparcj saiil 1,� is ��ied.....5200.00 �i�nual f�� � Ch�nye ai contractor. .....575.OG a Tent�l�:��i � � � .�<�� �� (ternE�or�ry only- �7hr�;G.-ilay rn,�xii���urn): .,,,.:>50A0 = r_�_MA 1r�i(E � �_jduri, � , � , . .:, :�,ly) ;i�;;� -��.:� A Plans revision fee (fo; ;�ibsi.uiti-�ily revis�ci t�lans): f�i<�t fee: ...,.S15.00 I'lans revision fee (Ior niiiior r�;vi::irr��a to ��lans): Fl�t fee: .....�a45.OQ � LosE pei�mit card or lost plr�ns fHe: ,,,..�40.00 ,,. , • �IC�I�3�1<1i1�:� . .`.� a l�Tl F2(!'F • f�ii. i ';�Or,tlif.3� Gqil1�P.Ct10(1 �Q.��; edC,h r�:��itt � I ?: .i,il�)�t � �.t��,1!!) �: ;��,�,'r,� 7. WORK WI 3`;; �,, >; �,. �„! i After the fact ��e+�r�iii i<, �, i��� ti��ork dor�e viithoui t�enefit of a pennit. F'rice for aitar #he fact permits will be �ssessed to each cateyory, I��iil�li��r�. E�I�niit�inq, electrical, mechanicai, :��+:�., an�i roofinf� ak do�ihle the r2gular pennit fee , ,. ,, , � �.., �� �.. � �1:�, . ;1 Extensinn of a perrnit ii no ne;�r cocle:; �ifE' in effect: .,...$75.Q0 Extension o# a permit if new codes are in effect: .....1°l0 oi valu��tion. 1, f��+.' tif� �41�.1�"fl �� !! iI� t1Y�i � fi' !) � , ���,�1 11t� }i.1�7:4L `��_ ���lll�fl_ f:l'I11�f5 Illil �8 BXfOiI(jGt� idli��ilt1�, dl{li iUl d}_�i_�IUU �i;�t't4 t� r{� ,+�-"-- �: ions shall be_requested in wriiingb�! thepermit_applicant and derrioi�s�r:+t� j��.<t�ti:+r�l�. �,��r:�, Arci�i��+��! ��I:_,�� rr:krieval fee $25.00 per request, copies priced per F,S. § 119.U7�1)(aj. It a perini't expires, renewal o( the expiiecl ��eriiiit si�all require the payment ��� the full f�erniit fne in efic�;i ai ti�e time ofi rene�.vaL Suk�j�ct to the appr�v��l of th� t�nii�iir�g oi'�icial, one nr inoi��;, not tc� exc�ed four, a•equests fur ��ei�nit f.;tter�:�ions can fie ms�rle ��ri��r to the expiration of a perrnit. Ho�,ve�; �;r, in no event sh�ll extansions be granted by the building Qfiicial on projects �,vl�icl� have receiveci variances s;}ecial exce�rtinns, and site plan r�vie4vs which have otheiviis� lai�s�d pur�uai7t to chapter 78. : i. � �� ',eairi::�>ection f�:es for rejection of work due to faulty construction, tivork not ready, failure to call for insper,tion, ►vork �>vcre�i ii�>, work not per plans, andlor no accti�ss (liftsllad�lers) to jobsite: �lat fee: .....�10t).00 � �;��si�<:d insu� �. � ��� � � :;re iiiuluderi v��t�ii�� �,c�ul_lr i�u�idiriypern�iit iees. �.i �;� ,� u.00 ea.�must be paid prior to am further inspections beina scheduled • Special tcourtesvl insnections where no aermit fee has been Qenerated �54.00 • After hour inspections $75.Q0 per hour; f2) hour minimum • After an initial insgection and one subi sequent reinspection for the same code violation specifically and continuousiy noted in each reiection, each subsequent re-inspection_shall be �!400.00 each aer FS 553,80_j2�cj 10,. REFUND POLICY Requests far refunds of per�nit fees paid rnust b� submitted to withir� 30 days of the date of issuance of the petmit, There shall b2 no raPu��ds of the piai� subinittal and revietiv fee paid at th� time of ��pplication for p6f171�t. I(I:<i�� -•ii ��� i1{s I1tY I il�l;�i; (11)(.i! V1UI.; �7�i:. � r�;111� k.��l�if)�B:iRl:)t1�ilr `T.�1�� �)111='��'! ��. i�dt.5d%. 11. EMFk�_,! �,'�:'; ;:�o„i( ..____ _ _ 'Alhere equipment replacements and repairs inust be perforrned in an emergency situ<�ti�n, the permit application shali be subrnitted witiiin the next �aorking business day to the building official, v�itl�out doiihle fee. � FLOODPLA(N DEVELOPMENT FEES A Floo_dplain Deve lopment Permi jFDP,Lis re quired for aii deve lopmen t�r o'el CtS p within the limiks of the floodplain. Devel opmeni acfivilies determinerf not to be i n_a fl oodpl ain are. n�t_ assessed a fee. completed 800dpiain application form should be_ subrnitt�ci, �31ong witt�„ aopiicable s do cumentatio n to the Buildinq Department at V illaqe Hail. Please check ���ith !he_F I�g for a determinafion if a r OpOSe dev withi the comm un� flood frinqe. in order for a Der aRp lication to be initiallv acce,�ted for review the appropriate fees must frs� be subm itteci, C hecks are to be made �a yabie to Vllaqe of Tequesta. Once the permif submittal is determined to be in com �ance wit l he pfovisions o the Flood Damage Preyention Or�inance of the Viliage of Teguesta the�piication is approved for ep rmitling_ Phased oro�ects shall be charqed separate fees for each phase requiriny separate reviews. Fees collected are non-refundable. 1. Determination Fees: • initial Fiood Zone Determination Ino fee • Letter of Fioodpiain Map Determination for insurance Purposes • 550.00 • Floodalain Determination Requirinq Site Visit - 5125.00 � • Fiood Elevation Certificate and Review - 8100.00 2. Residential Permits: • New Habitable structures — single familv detached dwellings room atlditions, pools -�250.00 flat fee • Accessorv structures aermit - Non Habitable sheds, qaraqes, decks, pool houses, outdoor kitchens, fences - 575.00 flat fee • Substantial fmprovement, or Substantial Reaair - 5250.00 flat fee The Flo�dalain Manager will use the market va lue of ihe buii ding, less l as dete rmined �t he tax o�ce. Shouid the ap�lic�nt disa rg ee wilh jhis,yalue a certifed apprais:al tt��,t uses the Cost Approach Method to delermine the building's �._....._ _ current value mav be suhmitted. If the value of improvement is qreater lha 50% of market yalue ihe�ro�f;r.► is � substantial_improvement bv definition; re uirin the strucfure be elevated to the desiqn flood elevation. 3. Non•Residenti Permits • N Com mercial structures - 35 0,00 p lus 75.00�per hoiir or,p ortion thereof • Substanti im rovement, or Substantiai Repair —$35 $75.00 �er hour or portion thereof The Flood�lair� Manacler wili u�e the m�rket_ o f ihe buildin . Ig ess lancl as deterrnined by the tax offce._;>h�ulci ihe apalicant disagree wikh this value, a certified aoaraisai that uses the Cost Approach Method to determi fhe buil�in 's current value may be subm itted. If ih value of im�royem. is qrea than 50%o mar value the proiect is a substanbal improyement by_defnition� r, e4uirin tg he structure be elevated to the design flood elevation. 4. Sm�r1l-Scale Development Permits - resi dential singieparce IandscaAinq, smallponds, minor filVgradinc�retaining wa ils, utilily crossinqs, citiverts, sewer, dsbris removal�,�125 �0 flat fee LarqP-Scale Development Permits - Fl oo�l�in siiidies� Fl�odway,._encro new or ex�ar�detl_s�ab�iivisi��n� watt�rcgurse �Iterations, I�ridges; flood control structures: multi _unit d4veilings. ofher proiects as delermined by ihe iloodU►ain nrt3nac�er, -,_�65(I.OD, 5. Inspections: . Flo odplain Sitelnspec (3) • 5l25,0 initial inspection each additi ;, i • Flood•Proofed Structure tnspectionlCertificatinn_(rorramE:rdai oniy) - $175.Uti 6. Revisions: • Minor Revisi - rev_ie or ap�r�,ve�i flt�r�d��l�in t7errnill<.�p�licaliun - 150,00 + Maior Revision__previ�usl_y revrF wed Qr ap��r«�����i.tioo�i��l,�u� s��ynn�fii��opiic�±li��n repuires a la icanl to re-applY and,�ay ne �ees • Floodplain Man Revision (LOM� • Variance Apulication • 51,500.O�lus rec�uired advertising at cost 7. Exfensi 90 da s ma��150.00 must be recLuested in writin�rior_t exp iration and demansUa iust�fiable_cause. E Xpif ed appii calions a�d�ermits shali reguire a new �icalion and new fees shall a��r, �plications submitted after development activities have commenced shali be assessed a 8250.00 fine and permit fees sha be doubled. Viola tions mav 6e fined up to $250.�0 each dav the violation remains. The Floodalain Manaaer mav assess additional fees or require third aartv review at cas! bv a aualified professional of the Viliage's choosinq at the apalicanYs expense Projects saecificativ owned and funded bv the Yillaqe of Teauesta are exempt from fee charaes, _ �_' ' .-� 1r ..>'S t''i0 �r �l%, ' � _ , ror��i �orr-.(s}: ._. t�� .�. F.ilikor's nn4e-- Per tl�e city's request, tha perrnit fees are hereii� set out. t;,oss ieferencE _�'.,riniz �t;es, § 1d•159 ei seq.